386YE Spring Equinox Synod judgements

Overview

During the Spring Equinox 386YE Summit, the Imperial Synod raised 210 judgements.

Statement of Principle

Judgement 4

• Assembly: Highborn
• Raised By: Doctor Lysimachus
• Judgement: While we Highborn are righteously committed to ensuring the Cold Sun is extinguished, we must not forget the other threats we still face and fight. While we focus on the Cold Sun on our doors and must prepare for Grendel on our shores, the Vallorn remains the greatest spiritual threat to the Empire and is no dormant threat. We formed the Grey Pilgrims to aid Navarr to end this threat, not just keep it at bay for another 1,000 years for others to deal with. In accordance with Sian Eternals statement to Navarr, once the Cold Sun have been snuffed out, even as we keep an eye upon the Grendel, we return to ensuring the Vallorn are eventually given a right permanent kicking in! When the time comes for just to act, whether sooner or later, we will Act with certainty.
• Outcome: Upheld (332-0)
• Notes: The Grey pilgrims were initially founded to oppose the threat of the vallorn.

Judgement 7

• Assembly: Dawn
• Raised By: Vivaine Knotes
• Judgement: The Dawnish gave the Empire the Test of Arms, a minimum acceptable standard all combatent citizens shall be trained to by the Empire at no cost to themselves. But since when have we Dawnish settled for the minimum? Should we not strive for our acceptable standard to be higher than other nations? We would ask the nation of weavers and knights, what measures can we collectively take to ensure our minimum training surpasses that of the Imperial Test of Arms. Can the wisdom of our mentors, the magic of our witches or the establishments we build raise our bar higher for all of those Dawnish who fight for the Empire... In time, the other nations may follow. Let them, and we will raise the bar again. For too long has the Empire complacently accepted the same standard.
• Outcome: Upheld (214-58)

Judgement 8

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Eska Harakkadottir
• Judgement: It is better by far to try and to fail than to fail to try. Day mages of the Empire, what is your Ambition? Despite being found guilty of treason, and attracting the attention of Cold Sun to the Empire through a series of unwise decisions, Skywise Gralka remains Arch Mage of Day unchallenged. The Synod calls upon the Conclave and its Grand Masters to uplift and encourage those with Courage, Ambition, and Pride to challenge for the position of Arch Mage of Day.
• Outcome: Upheld (1018-532)

Judgement 9

• Assembly: Loyalty
• Raised By: Able the Taller
• Judgement: Together we forge an unbreakable chain stretching across our Empire. Each pilgrim is a thread in the net, a single link connected to many, strengthening and supporting one another, building up our fellows. Your Loyalty is not a precious gem to be hoarded away but a Bright Burning Brand to drive away the darkness of isolation. It is only through building towards the loyalties where all can hear, seek out those who share your feelings, and reach out across any boundary, be it regional, territorial, or even national. With Virtue we can build WONDERS and work MIRACLES. With Loyalty we will inspire the Empire to be the Storm of Change our Emperor commands and build the future that every citizen deserves.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (496-0)

Judgement 10

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Creighton Blackewater
• Judgement: It will soon be two years since the liberation of Rachensgrab, and yet even with three successful statements of principle there has been no mandate or any indication that the former slaves have had their stolen prosperity returned to them. Let us prove that, we the Synod, stand by our virtue and call upon the Empire to raise a fund to be distributed to all former slaves of Rachensgrab living in the Empire. Propserity Provides.
• Outcome: Upheld (1382-164)
• Notes: References the events following the assault on the aerie of the slave lords of Rachensgrab in Winter 384YE, and the judgements of Winter 384YE judgement 165 Autumn 385 judgement 75, and WInter Solstice 385 judgement 162. The majority of the slaves freed in the fall of Rachensgrab were taken in by the Commonwealth, with only a few choosing to make the journey to the Empire. There is no Imperial contact with the nations of the northern Sea of Steel where Rachensgrab once lay but recent developments have provided an opportunity for Imperial fleets and military units to visit the area around Rachensgrab, as detailed in the Say her name wind of fortune.

Judgement 12

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Elagabala
• Judgement: Wisdom calls for listening to expertise; applying what one knows, and finding practical solutions. The Sevenfold Path are the second-oldest Conclave Order; for centuries they have been responsible for ensuring the powers of Conclave are deployed in line with the Way of Virtue. They have held Conclave to account time and time again, and uplifted souls in Virtue over and over. The Synod should support the work of the Sevenfolk Path by encouraging Virtuous magicians to join the Order, seeking their expertise in the Virtuous application of magical might, and bequeathing them liao and other materials that will support their manifesto. The Sevenfold Path serves as a bridge between Synod and Conclave - we encourage Synod to make use of that bridge.
• Outcome: Upheld (918-258)
• Notes: Refers to the Sevenfold Path Conclave order.

Judgement 14

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Ser Sable
• Judgement: When Dogri Thulebane refused to give up Skarsind we responded with the Iron Helms. When some of the people of Bregasland sided with Mathilda Fisher and her Jotun Masters we responded with the Magistrates. Why then when certain Urizeni in Spiral cede from the Empire in open rebellion do we respond with the olive branch and concessions. Yes since the fall of Britta the title of Warmage has been held mainly by Urizeni but I remind you that the first Warmage was a Warwitch named Jayne de Severnford it has never been a national position! I call on all nations to look to your Loyalty to those amongst you who may covet the title of Warmage and stand against this attack on their ambition if this title were made a national position under the rebels coercion. NO TO WARMAGE BEING A NATIONAL TITLE!
• Outcome: Upheld (774-718)
• Notes: Refers to the complex political situation in Spiral, most recently discussed in the The three pillars wind of fortune. The Warmage is an Imperial title that advises the Imperial Military Council on magical matters. The Imperial Senate voted to make the Imperial Warmage an Urizen national title during the summit.

Judgement 16

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Lenarius Ankarien
• Judgement: Our conflict with Asavea is not merely political, it is a moral and spiritual conflict as well. Moral, because the Empire stands against slavery, whereas Asavean society stands upon the backs of slaves. Spiritual, because their desperate dependency on imaginary deities holds back from achieving their highest potential through experiencing the virtues. Their priesthood is corrupt, thinking only of preserving their own power, and not of the good of their people. The Synod should do all it can to aid followers of the Way in Asavea, so that its people may be free to live in Virtue.
• Outcome: Upheld (1738-12)
• Notes: References the war with the Asavean Archipelago, and virtuous sects there as discussed in the Parts of speech wind of fortune.

Judgement 21

• Assembly: Highborn
• Raised By: Rinnah of the Shattered Tower
• Judgement: A year ago, Kirenna called for every Freeborn citizen to contribute whatever they could to support the raising of the Holy City at Bastion. Unasked, the Freeborn came and named their price. Highguard paid. Since, the Freeborn have faced an unprecedented storm of adversity, but have never wavered in their commitment. To live Virtue is to embrace it, and the virtue of every Freeborn citizen who contributed will echo through history for a thousand years. The Highborn recognise the Prosperity displayed in their labour, sweat and toil and invite the Freeborn to send a delegation of Sutannir to teach in Bastion upon its completion. They have earned their place alongside Highguard and should be welcomed to spread their perspective on the Way to pilgrims. Only though these bonds of kinship can the Grand Inspiration enable the Way to reach every soul in existence.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (457-0)
• Notes: Refers to the Grand Inspiration of the Way being raised in Bastion, introduced in the Blood will thicken wind of fortune.

Judgement 22

• Assembly: Highborn
• Raised By: Dagon of the Shattered Tower
• Judgement: A year ago, Friar John of the Mourn called for every citizen of the Marches to contribute whatever they could to support the raising of the Holy City at Bastion. The Marchers did so unasked, in recognition of the bonds that bind our Nations, our Empire and our Faith. Pride in small things, loyalty to great ones, the virtue of every Marcher citizen who contributed will truly echo through history for a thousand years. The Highborn recognise the Loyalty displayed in this unity of words and deed and invites the Marches to send a delegation of Monks and Friars to teach in Bastion upon its completion. They have earned their place alongside Highguard and should be welcomed to spread their perspective on the Way to pilgrims. Only through these bonds of kinship can the Grand Inspiration of the Way reach every soul in existence.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (457-0)
• Notes: Refers to the Grand Inspiration of the Way being raised in Bastion, introduced in the Blood will thicken wind of fortune.

Judgement 28

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Aspar
• Judgement: "It is the Empire's destiny to unite the world under the Way" - Emperor Vesna, 385YE. Many Asaveans yearn to embrace the Way. The Fire of Virtue smoulders on the archipelago. It is our duty to nurture this flame. It is our duty to show Asavea that the power of virtue exalts all. It is our duty to show the Asaveans that they have the courage and ambition to throw off the yoke of their masters, to reject the folly of their false gods, to remove the boot placed upon their neck and break the shackles of slavery that holds them from their highest destiny. Virtue lies in choice and action. There will be conflict, there will be blood. Consequences are the price of Ambition. We are willing to pay the cost.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (2326-62)
• Notes: Refers to the situation in the Asavean Archipelago, some details of which can be found in the Parts of speech wind of fortune.

Judgement 31

• Assembly: Dawn
• Raised By: Claude Deeds
• Judgement: To convert nonbelievers to the Way requires both words and deeds. It is not enough to say we wish to unite the world under the Way. We must also take courageous actions to do so. Let the Troubadours of Dawn study well how the Free Folk have been brought into the Empire, and into the Way. Dawn has led this charge. We listened to their questions. We defended them in the Synod. At the House of the Proffered Hand, in Astolat, the liberated now receive guidance in our faith. There are lessons here to learn. Let us learn them, and seek opportunities to put them into practice. Let us have the Courage to walk the long path of conversion - within our borders and beyond them.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (408-0)
• Notes: Talks about the Free Folk, discussed most recently in the Parts of speech wind of fortune.

Judgement 34

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Lord Severin de Rondell
• Judgement: Doctrine says that our spirits and our souls have a voice in the future. This our Empire is our voice, magnified by thousands. It is our responsibility in virtue to strengthen that voice, and not to weaken it. I do not command loyalty to the Empire but I say this, our ambition is too great for any one person to carry alone, our pride is in our fellows, our friends, and, yes, our foes, to work for the highest potential of the Empire is a virtuous thing. We are one Empire and we will strive together towards our shared future. We strive to act as the Exemplars and Paragons do to guide and teach benevolence that the actions marked by great virtue are those that benefit our Empire. For this benefits not just us, not just now but also our children and our future selves. We expect the greatest in virtue to have acted with benevolence and to bring the unvirtuous into the faith (salvation) as well as inspiring others to grow and build on their faith (inspiration). We believe that the way is a betterment for all thinking souls and that we as an Empire have a primary drive and responsibility to spread the way for that to occur the Empire must survive and grow to be made stronger as a vehicle of the Way, in this I ask the Empire to accept this charge. To best serve virtue our actions should benefit the Empire; through benevolence to inspire and bring salvation. All citizens should work to benefit the Empire through their virtuous acts over petty self serving or damaging choices. It is the responsibility of priests to guide those at Anvil in how best to do this and hold the Empire to virtue so that lands that have been lost may be regained and the Empire shall bring the way to the unvirtuous.
• Outcome: Not Upheld (530-532)

Judgement 38

• Assembly: Dawn
• Raised By: Lord Killian Mortére
• Judgement: To those who wield arms - test your might and claim your glory against the Deadwood Knight with courage in your hearts. Slay the wretched fiend within our borders! To those who wield words - sing the names of those who confront this challenge, spread their stories, exalt them with the utmost pride. Great deeds are eternal!
• Outcome: Upheld (200-32)
• Notes: Refers to the Deadwood Knight, also known as the Schlacta of Rot, currently threatening northern Weirwater and southern Karov. Discussed in more detail in the Momento mori wind of fortune.

Judgement 40

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Novella di Sarvos
• Judgement: Difference in faith should always be grounds for discussion, not alienation. The fire in our Emperor's inaugural address drives unity in our faith and in our culture. This passion has already placed the fear of Virtue into the hearts of multiple citizens of Axou and they have fled our lands. We do not wish to lose the richness of foreign culture and trade. We wish to be inviting to all scholars, traders, and thinkers of other nations, so that all may be enriched. We call on all citizens of the Empire to show Courage in meeting conflicting faiths, and to show Wisdom in the learning from others.
• Outcome: Upheld (582-218)
• Notes: Refers to inaugral address of the Throne, and presumably to the departure of Theodosia of Ipotavo who reportedly cut short her sabbatical in the Empire following the speech.

Judgement 41

• Assembly: Marches
• Raised By: Jedediah Boon
• Judgement: Never leave a river unbridged when you can build one out of rope. Never leave a rope bridge when you can build one out of wood. Never leave a wooden bridge when you can build one out of stone. We thank the Urizeni sword scholars who brought their teachings to our nation and did the heavy lifting on the first rickety bridge between our Nations. We invite the House of The Wanderer and the priests of Urizen to return again and this time friars of the Marches follow me to Urizen. Where we have disagreed in magic we will unite in faith two schools of virtue together in one cause; to share how our same religion manifests in the people of our different Nations. Let us break new ground with pride
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (222-0)

Judgement 43

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Bryce the Hare
• Judgement: It is a foreboding thought to face an enemy that feels no fear or apprehension, is stranger to both exult and lament, and knows neither bargain nor restraint. The Cold Sun is an enemy that is alien to us but it is also one that is barren to virtue and rejects inspiration. For that reason we possess a wellspring of power that is unknowable to the Cold Sun and we are stronger for it. Gird yourself with faith, remind yourself of what you seek to protect and draw inspiration from it. Create, and live in defiance of oblivion.
• Outcome: Upheld (1290-160)

Judgement 44

• Assembly: Freeborn
• Raised By: Azir i Smartha
• Judgement: We the Freeborn assembly support our sister nations in their claims for Mareave. We expect our sister nations to return our lands to us when they are once again Imperial. In Loyalty to our Empire. In Pride of our homeland.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (170-0)
• Notes: Relates to the Imperial Senate decision regarding Mareave and its allocation. More details can be found in the Into the spin wind of fortune.

Judgement 45

• Assembly: Wintermark
• Raised By: Veikko Bondforger
• Judgement: Wisdom knows that all knowledge is incomplete. We stormcrows have seen the Wisdom inspired by the sword scholars with the Holberg College of the Sword, and the way they have strengthened the Empire. We invite the sword scholars in hospitality to preach at the newly rebuilt Hall of Rund. Let's see how they can sharpen our wits and our talons.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (240-12)

Judgement 46

• Assembly: Urizen
• Raised By: Lochias
• Judgement: We are saddened that the Bone Pilgrimage do not extend into Urizen. However it is not our custom to preserve physical remains of the fallen we preserve their words. As the Imperial Orcs strive to build a great library in Skarsind, we call upon the scholars of Urizen to open our own libraries to the Sunstorm sept so that the library of Worth may contain the writings of their ancestors who dwelt among the spires.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (264-0)
• Notes: Relates to the Bone Pilgrimage, which encourages priests to support Imperial Orcs seeking out remains of former slaves and bringing them to the grand ossuary in Skarsind. This support is not extended by the majority of the Urizen priests, because the mandate enacting it in the General assembly did not receive a greater majority and so was rejected. Urizen funerary traditions were not extended to the orc slaves they held prior to the Orc Rebellion. As with the vast majority of orc slaves in the Empire, Urizen slaves were not permitted to read or write. There are very few records of anything significant that the orc slaves held in Urizen would have said or done.

Judgement 47

• Assembly: Highborn
• Raised By: Tabris son of Armisael
• Judgement: The Highborn National Assembly would like to thank the Free Folk for their generous offer of liao. We ask that it be directed towards the title of "Abbess of Reconciliation".
• Outcome: Upheld 372-0
• Notes: Relates to the offer made by the Free Folk in gratitude for Highguard work teaching their priests the liao ceremonies. Free Folk priests now support the Abbess of Reconciliation in their work.

Judgement 48

• Assembly: Wintermark
• Raised By: Vauraus "Prosperity's Forge" Korpittkoika
• Judgement: Do not fear to act only be shamed by inaction. Shacklebreaker Thanmir Hrafnar, the white Raven, has tirelessly committed themselves to serving the Empire. They were responsible for the greatest act of Prosperity the Empire has ever seen, the gifting of Skarsind to the Imperial Orc septs. Though controversial they did not falter in the wake of that heroic deed. They saw a wrong in the world that needed to be righted. Without their vision there would be no Liberty Pact. Their courage and ambition has forged the path that the Empire has now set upon. A politician that believes in the power of bringing people together rather than driving them apart. Wintermark is proud to add their tale to the Chronicle of Heroes.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (232-32)
• Notes: Thanmir Hrafnar has been added to the Chronicle of Heroes.

Judgement 50

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Corey Wayfarer
• Judgement: The Vates of Navarr take an Oath to deal with eternals and magic for the benefit of the community and as such they do not need our permission to act, be it in Conclave or in the performance of their duties. We will however hold them to their Oaths should they fail in fulfilling them.
• Outcome: Upheld (218-10)

Judgement 54

• Assembly: Highborn
• Raised By: Elkiah
• Judgement: We invite the Imperial Orcs to Necropolis to open the tomb of Emperor Ahraz, with the goal of allowing them to perform a ritual to reconnect with the lost ancestors among his bodyguard who were buried with him. May this act build a bond of Loyalty between our nations.
• Outcome: Upheld (382-0): the Greater Majority for this judgement was 398
• Notes: Refers to the Honour Guard of Ahraz, ten Imperial Orcs who lie in the tomb of Emperor Ahraz as his honour guard.

Judgement 55

• Assembly: Dawn
• Raised By: The Nobel Alys de Renard
• Judgement: For far too long the towers of Dawn have been left to lie fallow following their destruction by the Druj. No longer. In the name of glory and our great nation we must begin accepting proposals for projects to memorialize their loss. CDGV.
• Outcome: Upheld (284-0): the Greater Majority for this judgement was 286.
• Notes: The Towers of Dawn were ruined by the Druj during their conquest of the Barrens. A proposal to rebuild the towers was presented in Summer 385YE, but there was also the potential to "ask for proposals from the glorious architects of Dawn, to create something beautiful yet sombre to stand in place of the Towers."

Judgement 59

• Assembly: Wintermark
• Raised By: Rafe
• Judgement: The Prosperous are not selfish; all that is worthwhile is shared with those who deserve it. Fjellreven Hall pledges that the will provide liao such that any Winterfolk inspired by the deeds of Shacklebreaker Eska Crowspeaker, called Liberty's Song, to provide prosperity to Rachensgrab may receive a testimony as proof of their virtue. A hero has a name.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (252-0)
• Notes: Refers to the inspiration to provide prosperity to Rachensgrab, offering Imperial support to the unknown nations that lay in the shadow of the Aerie of the Slave Lords.

Judgement 61

• Assembly: Prosperity
• Raised By: Travid Longest Path
• Judgement: Virtue fund fines. Using fines to fund the virtue fund shows that Synod is rewarded and funded by unvirtuous acts, a message that risks threatening the confidence in Assemblies and the importance of The Way. Prosperity teaches to build, not take. The Virtue assemblies should instead look to fund and build the many Counting Houses across the Empire - to be reminders of Virtue and to inspire the citizens to give willingly to the Virtue fund - rather than take money from Senate that fund our armies and our infrastructure.
• Outcome: Not Upheld (90-202)
• Notes: Relates to recent changes made with regards to fines, discussed in detail in the Forwards and Rewards wind of fortune.

Judgement 62

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Corrado Filiarchi de Regario
• Judgement: Souls have a guardian a guide to take them to the Labyrinth, At the Winter Solstice 385YE the Reaper drew two lost souls to Anvil, one of the Marchers of old and one of the Navarr. I, and many others, beheld their arrival, their talk of the past, and their deaths and their fading from before our eyes as the Reaper himself guided them to the Labyrinth. I call that we must recognise the Reaper's role here, his ability to guide these souls to people who could heal them, and his assistance in letting them pass on. The Reaper is no simple piece of Leaguish Hearth magic, rather he has a place alongside the Way, and we must witness this.
• Outcome: Not Upheld (350-940)
• Notes: The Reaper is a character who participates in the Masquerade of the Reaper, a festival that takes place each Winter in the League.

Judgement 64

• Assembly: Marches
• Raised By: Father Edmund
• Judgement: Our land is our Pride. It is our Loyalty, our Prosperity, our virtue. The names given to our landmarks should reflect the virtuous heroes of our great nation, and our maps should not be stained by the names of the wicked and treacherous. Cast off the name Fisher's Rock, and let that landmark be known henceforth as "Amberlain's Stand".
• Outcome: Not upheld, withdrawn at request of the raising priest (96-62)
• Notes: Refers to Fisher's Rock in Bregasland.

Judgement 65

• Assembly: Prosperity
• Raised By: Katya Vassilova Reznikov
• Judgement: The Prosperous are not selfish; all that is worthwhile is shared with those who deserve it - the Freeborn both need our aid and are deserving of it. No food should be uneaten, no magic unused or coin unspent. Their armies are in decline, their lands blighted, and people suffer. Let us show the world that Prosperity provides, remembering the lessons of our exemplar, Zemress, we call for the Freeborn to be defended and fortified.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (218-10)
• Notes: Zemress is an exemplar of Prosperity, primarily recognised as an inspiration to those who work hard and invest that money for the benefit of others.

Judgement 66

• Assembly: Ambition
• Raised By: Eli of the Cenotaph
• Judgement: As we did in Sumaah, as we now begin in Asavea, the whole of creation will one day be united in the Way. Ambitious of the Empire, we should lead the charge in this matter. Seek out all who could aid in this abroad, whether they be hidden sects or souls waiting for the first spark to ignite.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (354-0)

Judgement 67

• Assembly: Prosperity
• Raised By: Ivana Petara Vodjavic
• Judgement: The Grendel and the Druj raid our territories, stealing our Prosperity and ruining our lands. We call on the teachings of Zemress, and encourage our corsairs, wagon raiders, reavers, and all truly prosperous individuals to strike hard, take back what is ours so that we may grow the Empire's prosperity and make ourselves safe.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (276-58)
• Notes: Zemress is an exemplar of prosperity who is an Inspiration to many who take up arms against those who threaten the Empire

Judgement 68

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Nekoda of the Shattered Tower
• Judgement: The Virtue Fund exists to reward virtue, not speed, just because a statement finishes scrutiny earlier doesn't mean it has higher priority than one finishing later. All Judgements of Rewarding should therefore be distributed at the same time on a basis of margin only, not at the time of the priest's choosing, let us let virtue alone decide.
• Outcome: Upheld (1480-150)
• Notes: Relates to the judgement of rewarding.

Judgement 69

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Nathair Autumngale
• Judgement: The scions of Oblivion seek to destroy that which we celebrate, our culture, our art, our expression. The Empty Hand left in their wake at Miaren trees devoid of life, calcified, petrified, and dead. This was meant to wound us, but it is an opportunity! Artists of Navarr, embrace our tradition of living art. Carve into these trees our Dance, paint upon their surface our story, decorate upon them with your passing all that our people are! Their attempts to harm us will become the very canvas upon which me mark their failure! In ink and blood!
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (324-0)
• Notes: Refers to the supernatural damage inflicted on Miaren by the Empty Hands army of Cold Sun.

Judgement 72

• Assembly: Urizen
• Raised By: Heminius of the House of the Wanderer
• Judgement: Architects of the Crucible! The Urizen National Asembly thanks you for your Ambition and Prosperity in supporting the transformation of Zenith. It is time for us to refocus our efforts however. With dangerous times ahead, we ask you to turn your attention away from producing light armour and towards producing heavy armour to better protect those who follow the Sentinel's path.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (230-0)
• Notes: The Urizen assembly has the ability to guide the artisans who work at the Crucible of Fate with regard to what magic items they make available to the Architect of the Crucible.

Judgement 75

• Assembly: Loyalty
• Raised By: Tarquinius
• Judgement: In Spiral the pattern of Betrayal by the Empire runs deep. Fleet action, children negotiation, black plateau, abandoned defense, treaty, Grendel cooperation, and finally people stripped away from the territory promised the just reward of accepting many of those. It is telling how truncated this list is, but the Empire has started to take action to restore its covenant with its people. We should... Nurture: the Spiral Urizeni who have remained imperial need to live well as imperial citizens, socially, economically, and politically. Protect: the Spiral Urizeni need to be able to retain their Spires and their identities as they help Apulian to grow in size and Influence. Secure: It needs to be abundantly clear that no virtuous citizen will stand for changes made to achieve these things being walked back.
• Outcome: Upheld (352-0): the Greater Majority threshold for this judgement was 354.
• Notes: Refers to the complex political situation in Spiral.

Judgement 76

• Assembly: The Way
• Raised By: Warsmith the Iron Way
• Judgement: Mareave is now under Imperial control. Citizens of the Empire, show the people of Mareave how virtuous The Empire is. Show them our Prosperity by trading with them. Show them our Ambition with the many great things we've built. Show them our Loyalty, and how fiercely we will defend any of our fellow Imperial Citizens. Finally, show them how the Apulian Orcs are integrating with the Empire and now are following the true virtues. Now is the time to spread The Way to them.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (322-24)
• Notes: Refers to the newly claimed territory of Mareave, discussed in more detail in the Into the spin wind of fortune. Also touches on the Grendel religion.

Judgement 77

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Silk Farkas
• Judgement: The Empire should name the continent that we live on.
• Outcome: Upheld (816-616)

Judgement 79

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Sian Eternal
• Judgement: It is time to stop seeing the Vallorn as a dormant threat to be dealt with later. It is a danger that lies within our Empire's borders that holds countless bodies and souls. Most notably it keeps two exemplars, the founders of our nation, in torturous stasis. The grey pilgrims of Highguard and questing Knights of Dawn did not join our cause simply to walk the trods for another thousand years. They join us in the war to eradicate the ancient abomination and fulfill our Nations ambition to see the end of the vallorn for good. It is time to act with wisdom and forethought but act nonetheless.
• Outcome: Upheld (214-0)
• Notes: Refers to the vallorn, and the recently completed research regarding its destruction, as well as the grey pilgrims of Highguard.

Judgement 81

• Assembly: Urizen
• Raised By: Solas of the Spire of the Waxing Sun
• Judgement: The highest inspiration of the Way is the spiritual truths it describes. Instead of contributing resources to a "new holy city" we call on the Questors of the nation to bring forth theories to be debated and tested. Let revelation be our contribution to this project to inspire.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (210-10)
• Notes: Relates to the "grand inspiration of the way" introduced in the Blood will thicken wind of fortune. It also calls on questors, Urizen who regard the Way of Virtue as an unfinished work, seeing the Doctrines of the Faith as incomplete revelation.

Judgement 82

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Eirlys Blackhawk
• Judgement: We know very little about the origins of liao, other than it was refined from vinum for the first time in Therunin. An under-celebrated part of our history. We encourage Navarri citizens to dig deep in their records, check their steadings' or stridings' stories and songs, to seek any information they may have on the founding of such a vital resource to the Empire.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (320-0)
• Notes: The Minister of Historical Research has the power to commission historical research into historical events.

Judgement 85

• Assembly: Urizen
• Raised By: Kasjay
• Judgement: The Net of Heavens has aligned the open hand of co-existance has been extended to us in Spiral. The bonds of loyalty, pride in our legacy call us to accept. Courage calls us to face this new path boldly. Vigilance calls us to watch over the black plateau. I call Urizeni spiralites to return to Spiral and rebuild their lost spires at virtues call.
• Outcome: Upheld (156-40)
• Notes: Refers to the complex political situation in Spiral.

Judgement 86

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Callista of the Dark Shard
• Judgement: Enchanting a personal resource to improve its production is a prosperous act. So too is using a ritual to enhance the reach of a priest's voice so that more people are drawn to their congregation. Synod priests should seek to use these enchantments to draw more people to the Way.
• Outcome: Upheld (1230-278)
• Notes: Enchantments that improve the production of a personal resource, or enhance the abilities of a citizen to lead a congregation, are created using ritual magic. The Sevenfold Path Conclave order works closely with the Synod to explore virtuous use of magic.

Judgement 88

• Assembly: Dawn
• Raised By: Chauntecleer Words
• Judgement: The fourth army of Dawn has been commissioned Summer 384 and since then has mustered without any clear guidance from the National assembly as to its nature. We propose: to create an army of the Black wherein those of noble ideal serving do so under the guise of a black knight. Let us create an army whose principles are to create outcomes with the most Glory for Dawn and the Empire and rise up those with whom it fights. We have passed in the last two years multiple statements regarding the Black Knight and this is in accord with them all and in particular that they are not solely restrained to the tourney. Black Knights have fought through the Sentinel Gate, aided the Militia, freed slaves, and represented Dawn to other nations. It would be inspirational thing to see what glory the purest expression of Dawnish spirit could achieve as an army.
• Outcome: Upheld (248-92)
• Notes: THe "black knight" is a role tied up in the hearth magic of Dawn whereby heraldry is obscured to conceal one's identity. The role is often taken by knights-errant who participate in tourneys as if they were nobles. Previous judgements include those from Summer 383YE, Spring 384YE, Spring 385YE, Autumn 385YE, and Winter 385YE.

Judgement 89

• Assembly: Loyalty
• Raised By: Halkyon of Sojourn's Heart
• Judgement: Loyal Urizeni Spiralites, exiles and refugees, the Empire has shown its loyalty to you by opening the way for you to return home. Our forebears endured war, occupation, and catastrophe. In their triumphs and sacrifices we find the seeds of our loyalty. Do not let their Legacy wither. As the Empire is inextricable, so too is our identity as Spiralites. Spiral is no longer in Urizen; the devotion of our hearts commands that we ensure Urizen is always in Spiral. Return to our lost spires and show that our loyalty to Spiral, to Urizen and Empire can remain undivided.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (358-10)
• Notes: Refers to the complex political situation in Spiral.

Judgement 90

• Assembly: Vigilance
• Raised By: Prince Bishop Jonah Yakovitch
• Judgement: We call all citizens to be vigilant to the machinations of the eternal Agramant. This cannibalistic horror who is under a declaration of enmity has cultists in the Empire who are grinding up people and putting them in food products. Seek out trusted suppliers of sausages until those responsible have been captured. Be Vigilant for the last surviving Agramant cultists of the Black Drop, Divina Inquilina di Tassato Regario. She is to be captured alive. Report sightings to the inquisitor of Vigilance.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (226-0)
• Notes: References the Childer of the Black Drop, a coven dedicated to the wicked eternal Agramant who has been an enemy of the Conclave throughout almost all of Imperial history. See also Judgement 125.

Judgement 91

• Assembly: Dawn
• Raised By: Earl of Fools
• Judgement: Deadwood Knight, the heart of Dawn lies in challenge and test, and in this the House of Fools offer thus. A test-of-mettle, to fight our champion, ungirded, with steel undrawn, in manner of your choosing.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (338-10)
• Notes: This judgement seems to relate to the Deadwood Knight (also known as the Schlacta of Rot), a creature currently terrorizing northern Weirwater and southern Karov. It seems to be addressed to the knight directly, but it's not clear that the creature has any access to Synod judgements. Further details can be found in the Momento mori wind of fortune.

Judgement 92

• Assembly: Loyalty
• Raised By: Arsenio Sanguineo Rezia di Tassato
• Judgement: The truly virtuous are loyal even through hardship and misfortune. The attacks by the cold sun were a profound disturbance of the military balance pushing our armies to the brink of endurance. Led by a swift and decisive response from the military council, citizens from all over the Empire rallied together to defy this new enemy. The virtuous lift each other up; let us celebrate their peerless commitment to the defense of the empire and encourage our armies to draw strength from the bonds they have forged on campaign
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (438-0)
• Notes: Refers to recent campaigns against Cold Sun, including those following the Autumn Equinox, and after the Winter Solstice.

Judgement 93

• Assembly: Loyalty
• Raised By: Anastasiya Luashovna Volkov
• Judgement: The virtuous lift each other up. While The Golden Pyramid manifesto lends itself easily to prosperity, we note their methods have been in line with loyalty in recent years for which it should be recognised. Providing access to an Autumn auction so our assembly could recover a religious artifact; supported artisans to empower the Crucible of Fate in Zenith; helped the Orcs of Skarsind uncover their wealth; supported multiple Throne candidates to gain conclaves endorsement including our new Emperor. These are all excellent examples of how conclave can operate in a virtuous way while also inline with their own manifesto.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (414-0)
• Notes: Refers to the Golden Pyramid Conclave order. It also seems to reference a recent auction held by the eternal Callidus, their support with the creation of the Crucible of Fate in Zenith, and their role in prospecting for wealth in Skarsind.

Judgement 95

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Fenrys Burning Branch
• Judgement: Last season the Navarr national assembly denounced cruel Tactics. As a thorn, someone who has made fighting their trade, I would propose otherwise. When you are trying to build a house you have many tools. You cannot cut a plank of wood with a hammer, you cannot sink a nail with a saw. We are building an Empire and tactics are our tools. Cruelty is a tool, the same as mercy or cunning. Just because a hammer is not right at this time doesn't mean we won't need it later.
• Outcome: Upheld (174-140)
• Notes:May refer to Judgement 128 raised at the Winter Solstice.

Judgement 96

• Assembly: Loyalty
• Raised By: Sufyan i Zuhri i Erigo
• Judgement: I have journeyed to Asavea bringing word of our Way and The Empire's doctrine and support for the virtuous rebels there. What I saw was wonderful - I have never seen such hope in virtuous eyes as when we told them the Empire wanted to support them and welcomed them into virtue. But the support we must send them as only started. We have forged a bond and now we must keep our word and our loyalty. We call on those loyal to our young siblings in virtue to find any and all ways they can to send their support to the virtuous rebels in Asavea. Virtue exults
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (355-0). The Greater Majority threshold for this statement was 354.
• Notes: Refers to the missionaries and wayfarers recently sent to the Asavean Archipelago, discussed in more detail in the parts of speech wind of fortune.

Judgement 97

• Assembly: League
• Raised By: Estella Lucati
• Judgement: Be vigilant! Avoid the Black Plateau!
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (252-12)
• Notes: Relates to the Black Plateau, which squats in the middle of the region of Screed in Spiral.

Judgement 98

• Assembly: Pride
• Raised By: Emil Radam von Temeschwar
• Judgement: The Empire takes pride in its history. We look to the example of Paragon Empress RIchilde, to exalt the independence of our generals and our military concil who spread the Way and expand the reach of virtue. Emperor Vesna Borkovna Prochnost raises up our military council with pride that the bodies of state shall have the autonomy to act with virtue.
• Outcome: Upheld (164-62)

Judgement 101

• Assembly: Wisdom
• Raised By: Tuuli
• Judgement: Asking no questions begets no answers. Wisdom is not always knowing the answer, Wisdom is finding the right question I call upon dedicants of Wisdom to ask themselves how their silence aids the Empire.
• Outcome: Upheld (192-50)

Judgement 103

• Assembly: Highborn
• Raised By: Asher of Cantiarch's Hold
• Judgement: In Loyalty we should look out for one another. We are duty bound to protect all citizens. Sovereign Specific offers one such protection but costs many herbs. Blood Whelks can offer the same protection to many rather than one. In Wisdom we should learn how to breed them as an alternate to herbs.
• Outcome: Upheld (260-10)
• Notes: The Sovereign Specific is a potion that provides many different forms of healing and can be made by an apothecary versed in the art of the Master Medicinal. The "Blood whelks" are likely a reference to the giant blood whelks that seem to be found only in the frigid, monster haunted waters of the Sea of Snows near the Faraden port of Caitun.

Judgement 107

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Jakwine Stockherd
• Judgement: We praise the Loyal action of the Grey Pilgrim Marija, Dagon the Champion of Loyalty, and all who answered their call to slay vallornspawn and rescue Thorns. In turn, let Navarr demonstrate the bonds we have forged by guiding and protecting all Highborn who seek to explore Terunael ruins and keep alight their enthusiasm for exploration.
• Outcome: Upheld (126-0)
• Notes: Appears to be in reference to the chance to prevent the slaughter of wounded thorns during the summit.

Judgement 108

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Hieronymous Dowland
• Judgement: Loyalty binds us! The love between Marchers and Dawn stands as true as ever. Robert Dunlain gave his life and stands testament to Courage. The Dawnish sing his name.
• Outcome: Upheld (726-124)

Judgement 109

• Assembly: Freeborn
• Raised By: Estivanico i Hayim
• Judgement: The Freeborn are the people not the land we live on but we will retake our lands rebuild and grow with prosperity. Family are the heart of the Freeborn and the dhomiro are the voices of the families serving with vigilance and wisdom as we seek to rebuild what was ours. We call upon those of the Brass Coast to acknowledge the importance of the council of Dhomiros in representing the families of the Freeborn, serving the Brass Coast with the same vigilance and wisdom they serve their own families.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (148-12)

Judgement 110

• Assembly: Marches
• Raised By: Nigel Hornbeam
• Judgement: We the Marcher Assembly accept the peerless kinship of Highguard and their unconquered to aid the beaters of the Mourn and the rest of the Marchers in patrolling our borders against the many incoming threats. We encourage the Beaters to report any sightings of peril to the Bailiff of the Downs.
• Outcome: Upheld (150-0). The greater majority threshold for this judgement was 173.
• Notes: Refers to the peerless kinship of Highguard, offered during the Winter Solstice. While the Highborn could offer aid without a statement from the Marcher assembly, many felt it prudent to ask for guidance rather than risk making matters in the Marches worse.

Judgement 111

• Assembly: Loyalty
• Raised By: Exarch Luke
• Judgement: Virtue lies in choice and action. Virtues power to exalt transcends the boundaries of soul, spirit, and species, guiding and inspiring both orcs and humans to their highest destiny. Through the practice of virtue orcs and humans develop the strength, knowledge, and enlightenment which marks their highest potential as thinking beings. The doctrine of Enlightenment recognises that all sentient beings are capable of inspiration, yet the Empire's history is made in the blood and soiled Earth of thousands of brutalized people who we have put under the indignation of torture, cruelty, and genocide. Virtue demands we are better, and now our Emperor commands it! The Imperial Senate's use of the classification "Barbarians" is comparable to calling those people nothing better than animals. Enabling us to do anything and everything we wish to them. Denying their personhood, denying their ability to achieve enlightenment. As such we urge those pilgrims who hold some Loyalty to the Empire to seek out your politicians, your senators, your priests, and make them listen. We must cry out together: "enlightenment is for all! All must be treated with basic rights and dignity!"
• Outcome: Upheld (306-69)

Judgement 112

• Assembly: Highborn
• Raised By: Hazelelponi of the Shattered Tower
• Judgement: Grey pilgrims we walk the trods after hearing Navarr's call, so I ask that we hear their call again. Five years ago our own Senators raised the motion to share the herbs of High Chalcis with the Great Forest Orcs. We as a nation are undeniably part of their history beyond treaties signed by the Empire. Navarr looked to their loyalty (judgment 56) and Loyalty teaches that the truly virtuous are loyal even through hardship and misfortune. Navarr recognises this, so we will be moved by their actions. If the Great Forest orcs are family to the Navarr than they are our neighbors, and we will guard their souls as we would any citizen of the Empire. We do not boast, we act. So we act now, and in doing so we may still yet inspire others to greatness
• Outcome: Upheld (379-0). The greater majority threshold for this statement was 398
• Notes: Refers to the Great Forest Orcs, to Judgement 56, and to the Senate decision to redistribute herbs to the orcs when they first came to Therunin as refugees from the Barrens.

Judgement 113

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Winifred Blackhawk
• Judgement: We the Navarr Assembly encourage our bards to take their songs far and wide even beyond our borders so that all may come to know Navarr.
• Outcome: Upheld (238-0)

Judgement 115

• Assembly: Freeborn
• Raised By: Anisa i Mevidian i Erigo
• Judgement: The Shining Pillar that stood in Free Landing is destroyed, but the vision it represents need not be. It was said that Guerra incorporated her enchanted dowsing crystal, empowered by the Day realm, into the Shining Pillar. As we retake Free Landing, we call on the Red Wind Corsairs to perform a daring raid on Free Landing, to seek through the rubble for Guerra's crystal, and call on Freeborn following to do likewise. Let the crystal grant us clarity and vision as we divine with Glass the future of the Brass Coast.
• Outcome: Upheld (49-0)
• Notes: After serving as a beacon to the Freeborn corsairs for almost the entire history of the Brass Coast, the Shining Pillar was destroyed in Winter 385YE. Where the Pillar once stood is a malestrom of chaos and destruction; there is unfortunately no rubble to be searched.

Judgement 116

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Zakal Antigouan Shatterhorn
• Judgement: Cold Sun tried to destroy our heart in attacking Miaren. Every song we sing, every item we craft, every act of creation is an act of defiance. In this way, to create, sing, and dance we ask all Navarr to join the fight.
• Outcome: Upheld (216-10)
• Notes: Refers to the attack by Cold Sun on the territory of Miaren, which is still ongoing.

Judgement 117

• Assembly: Vigilance
• Raised By: Wade Boggs
• Judgement: A bad apple in the bushel rots the crop. The narcotics produced and imported by the second order apothecaries guild of Kaban in Axos block the imbibers connection to the Way, and as such are a serious spiritual threat to the Empire. We urge Imperial citizens to practice Vigilance and disavow the use and possession of these substances.
• Outcome: Upheld (134-0)
• Notes: The Tunnels of Kaban are citadel in Axos. Specialist apothecaries such as Evander Slak and Hippolata of Kaban have been regular visitors to Anvil for a year or more, although some have recently declared an intention to curtail their activities in the Empire to a degree.

Judgement 118

• Assembly: Freeborn
• Raised By: Dayanara i Cabeza i Erigo
• Judgement: As priests of Virtue and the Way there is great Pride to be found in bringing the word of the Way and the Doctrine of Enlightenment to those who are lost. The leaders of Asavea have made clear they abhor those who preach the Way and that the cost of this actions is blood. Priests of the Brass Coast should draw on their Courage and Ambition to bring news of the Doctrine of Enlightenment to the citizens and slaves of Asavea alike. The souls of these people is in our hands and it is our duty to provide them guidance. Everything has a price, even saving the souls of those not following the Way.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (172-0)
• Notes: Refers to the recent effort to send missionaries and wayfarers to Asavea, discussed in more detail in the Parts of Speech.

Judgement 120

• Assembly: Wintermark
• Raised By: Saavi Heroes' Champion
• Judgement: The Thule have freed their slaves and their skeins need guidance. Mediators travel to the Silver Peaks, their eyes wide with vigilance. They take their trade and hospitality north. They live their lives with Virtue, and set an example to those who are searching, helping them find their path.
• Outcome: Not Upheld - Withdrawn

Judgement 121

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Mauriac
• Judgement: The virtuous apply what they have learned; our mandate is to spread understanding and to serve as an example of that understanding. When our judgements are based on subjective opinions, or done out of personal greed, we undermine the foundations of the spiritual duty with which we have been entrusted.
• Outcome: Upheld (606-394)

Judgement 125

• Assembly: League
• Raised By: Paulus Adelaar van Holberg
• Judgement: Holberg, greatest city in the World, also produces the greatest victuals in the World. Agramant, through his cultists, seeks to turn this fact against us! Citizens of the League, look to the Custodian of the Bloody Great Sausage for their guidance on where to find the best quality victuals.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (288-0)
• Notes: The Custodian of the Bloody Great Sausage is expected to spread fine quality Holberg victuals across the Empire, with a special emphasis on premium sausage. See also Judgement 90.

Judgement 126

• Assembly: Highborn
• Raised By: Sister Julliette of Balthazar's Vineyard
• Judgement: We praise the Loyal action of Grey Pilgrim Marija, Dagon the Champion of Loyalty, and all who answered their call to slay vallornspawn and rescue Navarr thorns. Let us take Pride in their achievements by joining our siblings in Navarr and sending forth units to explore the Terunael ruins.
• Outcome: Upheld (324-10)
• Notes: Appears to be in reference to the chance to prevent the slaughter of wounded thorns during the summit.

Judgement 127

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Caoimhe Tendfallen
• Judgement: The Montainans and the Great Forest Orcs are not one and the same. The assurances we extend to the Great Forest Orcs are not appropriate to the Montainians. However the Montainins are dear to our friends and their destruction will not benefit the Empire in Virtue or in pragmatism. We will not stand idly by if they are threatened.
• Outcome: Upheld (236-20)
• Notes: While the Montanian faction of the Barrens has been destroyed, a number of survivors - primarily children, young parents, those too infirm to fight, or those who opposed armed resistance - were offered unconditional sanctuary by the Great Forest Orcs.

Judgement 130

• Assembly: Wintermark
• Raised By: Ironvigil Rikke the Relentless
• Judgement: The Blood on Snow cult leader Maarik Goldentongue has lived too long, fleeing to the Silver Peaks. Now the Ambassador to Otkodov is elected as Kindra Surefoot, a Winterborn, the Thule have granted sanction to hunt her within that area. I call on the 'Mark's hunters, our scouts, our heroes to find and end her now before she can flee. We must root out and destroy this scion of evil. Hunt with me!
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (274-0)
• Notes: References Wintermark-Thule relations, discussed in further detail in the Say her name wind of fortune.

Judgement 131

• Assembly: Loyalty
• Raised By: Larkin Shrike, of House du Besté
• Judgement: The bird leashed to the hand cannot be called loyal only the bird which is allowed to fly free and still chooses to return to its masters hand is truly loyal. Loyalty is shown most strongly in the face of temptation and in the choices we are presented with. Citizens must be free to make their own destinies and pursue their own hearts according to their own loyalties. Being faithful when no other option is permitted is not loyalty. Only by being allowed to fly free can we truly judge the loyalty of our own flock. Loyalty should be chosen and not forced.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (360-0)

Judgement 132

• Assembly: Urizen
• Raised By: Clytemnestra
• Judgement: People of Urizen - mages, sentinels, sword scholars - come with me on pilgrimage to learn about Marcher land! Jedediah Boon of the Ore Hills inspired me with his pride in his land and his people and I want our people to learn about the pride and virtue of The Marcher's connection to their Land. Come with me in the Autumn. Let us learn of Marcher farming, Marcher pride, and let us help to bring the harvest home.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (186-0)

Judgement 135

• Assembly: Dawn
• Raised By: Leolaani
• Judgement: All hail Billimund and Tancred of the Emerald Dogs for their Ambition! All hail Arlen, Reeve of the Greenforest Fair, and all those who answered their call to slay vallornspawn and uncover a treasure trove of herbs. Let us honour their achievement and reap the reward of their glorious action by questing in the Greenwood and claiming the bounty within.
• Outcome: Upheld (156-10)
• Notes: Dawnish military units can take part in the quest against the vallorn adventure, which allows them to seek glory in the depths of vallorn-infested Brocéliande, facing vallornspawn, orcs, and perhaps even stranger things (such as monsters from the Spring realm), as well as exploring ancient Terunael ruins. The Emerald Dogs are an order of knights-errant who uncovered the trove of herbs mentioned.

Judgement 136

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Neala Blackhawk
• Judgement: The thorns have spoken, they find our national assembly to be "out of touch". To encourage cohesion within our nation chaplains have been appointed. It is wise to share knowledge and to guide the virtue of our thorns, scouts, and generals. We uphold: Ioan Longashdow as chaplain to the military council; Eirlys Blackhawk as chaplain to the Thorns and Zakal Shatterhorn as Chaplain to the scouts.
• Outcome: Upheld (140-88)

Judgement 137

• Assembly: Urizen
• Raised By: Aurum Nightingale
• Judgement: The Oblivion Sentinel has uncovered a Grendel plot to weaponise the Black Plateau. This assembly calls upon the priests of Urizen to make all haste to Spiral and provide spiritual protection to all Urizen citizens and our Urizen kin, that they might endure in virtue.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (224-0)
• Notes: See also Judgement 167

Judgement 138

• Assembly: League
• Raised By: Lia Adelaar
• Judgement: Citizens of the League, let us recognise our Empire siblings Highguard, who this summit completed their reckoning with us by delivery of the last of 50 wains. We acknowledge the reckoning complete and invite Highguard to contact the Bishop Estella the Wanderer to arrange a celebration together at the next Winter summit.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (284-0)
• Notes: See also Judgement 169.

Judgement 143

• Assembly: Varushka
• Raised By: Vaclav Mladenovich Kosti
• Judgement: Stand strong Varushka! The national assembly urges courage from the soldiery of Varushka to stand firm against the predation of the Schlacta of Rot! We call upon the military units of Varushka to band together to oppose its threat!
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (246-0)
• Notes: Refers to the Schlacta of Rot, also known as the Deadwood Knight, currently threatening northern Weirwater and southern Karov. Discussed in more detail in the Momento mori wind of fortune.

Judgement 144

• Assembly: Varushka
• Raised By: Amris Johan Merikovich
• Judgement: Our virtuous armies and citizens have succeeded in shattering the Cold Sun aggressors in Varushka through usage of the might of the Vards and the cunning of the Ushkans. However some remnants remain. We call upon all virtuous citizens to root out and obliterate any trace of the Cold Sun.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (256-0)
• Notes: Relates to the remnants of the Cold Sun in Blade of Skies army of scions who, with the defeat of their army, continue to threaten the people of Karov.

Judgement 145

• Assembly: Varushka
• Raised By: Drakov
• Judgement: Last summit we agreed to "give aid and access" to our friends, the Imperial Orcs in their Bone Pilgrimage. Now Skywise Karrak asks for our help to locate the bones and/or items of worth belonging to Tagga, mother of Thrace. She fell in Spring 323, fighting the Golden Axe in Korotny during the Rebellion. Cousins, search your stores, shelves, and secret places. Let us do all we can to help achieve the Ambition of one and build the Pride of many.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (258-0)
• Notes: Appears to refer to the orc Tagga who was the subject of recent research by the Lepidean Librarian. The circumstances surrounding her death strongly suggest her body was burned to ashes by the victorious Varushkans alongside those of the other orcs killed in the engagement where she died, making it extremely unlikely any of her remains persist today.

Judgement 146

• Assembly: Varushka
• Raised By: Milosz Casimirov Volny
• Judgement: Delev stands! Duzekani is burnt but Imperial! The Varushkan national assembly calls for the recognition of those Imperial heroes and troops from Dawn, Navarr, and Varushka for their courage in the face of oblivion!
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (246-0)
• Notes: Relates to the Battle of Delev and the defence of Duzekani against the Blade of Skies. The names of individual captains who supported the armies there can be found in the Imperial Roll of Honour.

Judgement 147

• Assembly: Varushka
• Raised By: Rooslan Stannich Prochnost
• Judgement: We the Varushkan national assembly recognize Vitaly Gregorovich Dukov and Vasiliy Krenyenkov Valeskai Strascovich's great prosperity which has enriched us all since the death of Empress Britta. Their hard work and prideful competition has led to the creation of the Iron Helms, the enlargement of the Golden Axe, the construction of the Iron Roads, the fortifications of the Grim Hold and Alexandra's Watch, and the construction of the Shrine of the Maze of Zoria. We thank them and applaud their virtuous contribution to the expansion of the Empire.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (220-12)
• Notes: The Assembly of Prosperity have the power to add citizens to the Roll of Benefactors as a public list of those considered to demonstrate great Prosperity.

Judgement 148

• Assembly: Varushka
• Raised By: Illya Nikovitch Volkov
• Judgement: The wise know that all knowledge is incomplete and the vigilant seek out the poison in their neighbour's fields. The national assembly of Varushka calls fro the creation of a "dark archive" of sovereign lore, where the virtuous citizens of Varushka may share their knowledge of the sovereigns, to better understand and examine the veracity of said knowledge.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (224-10)

Judgement 149

• Assembly: Varushka
• Raised By: Kalina Jadwigowna Piosnkowa Prochnost
• Judgement: We welcome the Highborn national assemblies expertise on Hatred, the blight that festered in the breast of their Pegasus for over a year. If they feel the general of the Iron Helms Has fallen to this spectre of Highguard's past or any other false virtue we invite them to bring their evidence before our assembly. If they have proof that the commitment of our soldiers to do whatever it takes to defend our Empire, and those they love, endangers their spirit or the spirits of those they fight, we again invite the Highborn to bring evidence of this oft repeated claim to our hearth so we may take action. Have caution that you do not find our ways unsettling or offensive simply because they are different to your own. War is not as clean as your beloved chessboard suggests but dirty is not synonymous with unvirtuous.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (222-14)

Judgement 150

• Assembly: Varushka
• Raised By: Konstantin Rabovich Bolotnikov
• Judgement: As partners in greatness for the last year, Varushka and Highguard have shared guidance and inspiration, most recently joining in full-voiced commitment to banish Oblivion from our borders. Varsuhka's vigilance also allowed us to guide our sibling away from their well-meaning but potentially disastrous mission to Otkodov. With the turning of the new year we should look to our Urizeni cousins. By their boundless ambition and our hard-won wisdom, we will challenge each other to reach new heights as partners in greatness.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (226-10)

Judgement 153

• Assembly: Urizen
• Raised By: Pallatius Dragonsong
• Judgement: Our territories have been twice cursed, both by Marcher citizens. From both seasons of casting, the casters are either dead, or have been declared sorcerers by members of their own nation. They have also been shunned by their national assembly. This is not, and will not be, a curse war between us. We have chosen not to retaliate in kind for we do not want to put the wider popuous through the hardships you have faced with poise and courage. There is strength in virtue. Rise up, not tear down, those we choose to stand next to.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (196-10)

Judgement 154

• Assembly: Dawn
• Raised By: Earl Ailsa Temerlaine
• Judgement: Varushka wants Dawn to "bow" to their traditions in regards to the Dho'uala and give it Imperial citizens in sacrifice. In simple terms, NO, SHAN'T. The details: we will not take actions that condemn souls and keep citizens from the Labyrinth. We will not engage in human sacrifice. We will not engage in idolatry. The Dho'uala already takes innocent souls. We do not bow.
• Outcome: Upheld (172-0)
• Notes: References the horror Dho'uala that lairs in the Semmerlak. Seems to reference the proposal to perform executions by drowning in the lake which was first proposed by the senator for Karov during the Autumn Equinox but withdrawn without being discussed in Senate. The senator for Karov went on to raise the motion again during the Winter Solstice 385YE where it was debated upon but was ultimately voted down.

Judgement 155

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Levi of the Navigators
• Judgement: I wish to publicly and personally apologise to Alderai the Fair, general of the Iron Helms, for the statement made last summit regarding their revocation. It was based on incorrect and ill informed information. Wisdom encourages us to recognise our mistakes and learn from them. I will use this as an opportunity to learn, to be certain of current information before putting statements forward and slandering an Imperial citizen.
• Outcome: Upheld (748-68)
• Notes: References Judgement 49 from the Winter Solstice 385YE.

Judgement 157

• Assembly: Wintermark
• Raised By: Eldrid Vestardottir
• Judgement: The mystics of Wintermark believe that the general of the Fist of the Mountain should and always be also a mystic in order to better lead by example and background.
• Outcome: Not upheld: Withdrawn (0-40)

Judgement 158

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Rhisiart Dancewalker
• Judgement: Liathaven is a tomb and a shame of our people. For too long it has been forgotten and ignored. The military council always state "next season". The time for action is now, as Navarr armies will seek its liberation, turn every ring, and every effort to liberate the birthplace of the trods. Liathaven lives!
• Outcome: Upheld (72-54)

Judgement 160

• Assembly: Freeborn
• Raised By: Asier i Elia i Guerra
• Judgement: The courageous stand up for what is right, even in the face of fear. The loyal stand beside their allies, even in hardship. The proud protect their home, and those they live alongside. In offering refuge to displaced Freeborn, and in the defence of Madruga against the Grendel and their former subjugators, the Asaveans. The Marracossans of Trajadoz demonstrated all of the above. They chose to act virtuously, despite their continued devotion to the plenum's false pantheon. We, the Freeborn, recognise their efforts, thank them, and stand beside them in Courage, Loyalty, and Pride in Madruga. Let their virtuous choice act as an example to all people throughout the world that anyone with a choice can choose virtue.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (128-0)
• Notes: The Marracossans are former Asaveans who fled to the Empire following the failure of their rebellion against the Plenum. The Senate ceded the largely abandoned town of Trajadoz in Madruga to them. During the recent fighting in Madruga, a number of Marracossan artisans joined the Imperial forces fighting the Grendel.

Judgement 166

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Athiel Westernborn of the Cenotaph
• Judgement: The inspirational acts of Alberto and Amika Acciai, Asavean Priests of the Way could not have spread without the invaluable support of the virtuous priests and wayfarers from every nation. We stand with all Imperial missionaries in Asavea and offer our full support and guidance to them, should they require it. We are ready to propitiate the spreading of the Way of Virtue.
• Outcome: Upheld (1054-0)
• Notes: Refers to the efforts to send missionaries and wayfarers to Asavea, discussed in detail in the Parts of speech wind of fortune.

Judgement 167

• Assembly: League
• Raised By: Fabin Costas de Sarvos
• Judgement: The Oblivion Sentinel has uncovered a Grendel plot to weaponise the Black Plateau. The assembly calls upon the priests of the League to make all haste to Apulian and Spiral, and provide spiritual protection to all citizens that they might endure in virtue.
• Outcome: Upheld (180-22)
• Notes: See also Judgement 137

Judgement 169

• Assembly: Highborn
• Raised By: Speaker Abraham
• Judgement: Citizens of Highguard, let us celebrate the completion of our reckoning with our Empire siblings the League. We hope to celebrate together at the next Winter summit to nurture our growing friendship.
• Outcome: Upheld (289-20)
• Notes: See also Judgement 138.

Judgement 170

• Assembly: Highborn
• Raised By: Tamar
• Judgement: Highborn! The Grendel seek to find and destroy a bridge that lies between Redoubt and Necropolis. With Vigilance and Wisdom, locate this bridge and bring ideas as to how it can be defended to your people and assembly.
• Outcome: Upheld (363-10). The greater majority threshold for this judgement was 393.
• Notes: This likely refers to the Courspan Bridge and the mystery surrounding it. See also Judgement 171.

Judgement 171

• Assembly: Urizen
• Raised By: Charito
• Judgement: Urizen. The Grendel seek to find and destroy a bridge that lies between Redoubt and Necropolis. With Vigilance and Wisdom, locate this bridge and bring any ideas as to how it can be defended to your people and assembly.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (218-0)
• Notes: This likely refers to the Courspan Bridge and the mystery surrounding it. See also Judgement 170.

Judgement 173

• Assembly: Marches
• Raised By: Rey Fosterbrooke
• Judgement: The Marchers are not striking this time. The Throne has acknowledged our grievances, and promised an address where they consider cursing Imperial territories acts of treason. Further as Master of Magic, that action will be taken. With these and other acknowledgements by Imperial bodies, the Marcher farmers choose not to put Imperial prosperity at risk, for repeated slights. Lets judge this field by its harvest.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (194-12)
• Notes: Refers to recent events involving Urizen and the Marches, further discussed in the Sound the bells wind of fortune. It's not clear which power of the Throne is being referenced here, as Master of Magic is a power of the Archmages.

Judgement 174

• Assembly: Highguard
• Raised By: Keziah
• Judgement: In these times - when our understanding of doctrine is rapidly changing under the guidance of a small inner circle of theologians at Anvil - it is important for the virtuous common citizens of Highguard to attend Anvil, so that they may hold their Assembly to account when they might err.
• Outcome: Upheld (262-0)

Judgement 175

• Assembly: Highguard
• Raised By: Aemon of the Suns of Couros
• Judgement: Highborn, be ever vigilant! The foul parasite of reality, the Whisper Gallery, have created abominations that wear the surgically removed faces of our sibilings as disguises. Stay away and report these sightings to the magistrates and your inquisitors.
• Outcome: Upheld (278-0)

Judgement 177

• Assembly: Urizen
• Raised By: Verres
• Judgement: The Empire plans to cast Foam and Spittle of the Furious Sea across the Bay of Catazar to hinder and strike at the Grendel. Urizeni of Redoubt and Spiral prepare for storms to come as we defend ourselves.
• Outcome: Upheld (166-8)
• Notes: This statement of principle did not receive a Greater Majority. As such, while it has been seen by many of the priests attending Anvil, judgements that pass with a lesser majority are not widely discussed outside Anvil.

Judgement 178

• Assembly: Highguard
• Raised By: Alessi of the Basilisks of the labyrinth
• Judgement: People of Necropolis have Courage. A flood is coming that you can mitigate with planning, Vigilance, and Courage.
• Outcome: Upheld (272-0)
• Notes: This statement of principle did not receive a Greater Majority. As such, while it has been seen by many of the priests attending Anvil, judgements that pass with a lesser majority are not widely discussed outside Anvil.

Judgement 179

• Assembly: The Marches
• Raised By: Jhonathen Piper
• Judgement: Marcher food fills the bellies of heroes. Our threat to strike has shown that some heroes have gone hungrier than others. We the Marcher Assembly call for farmers to charge Freeborn armies less, but the rest of the Empire's armies more. Marchers are Loyal to our allies, and our hospitality knows no bounds.
• Outcome: Upheld (108-12)

Judgement 182

• Assembly: Imperial Orc
• Raised By: Redhand Ikis
• Judgement: We remember all those who fell in the battle for White Storm Pass, we will not let them have died in vain, though the Cold Sun may unleash a fresh winter, we shall endure. Protect your lives, protect the great herd, protect the land. This is our home, we shall not falter.
• Outcome: Upheld (36-0)
• Notes: Refers to the engagement with the scions of Cold Sun threatening Whitelake.

Judgement 183

• Assembly: Freeborn
• Raised By: Anna Laya Del-Toro
• Judgement: Assembly calls upon citizens in the vicinity of the Great Grasses to practice Wisdom and Vigilance regarding the ongoing blight. Affected areas should be avoided at all costs. If you observe any new developments in the blight, the proper authorities should be notified immediately.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (140-0)
• Notes: Refers to the threat of the Blightheart in Madruga, and the dry partricians, as discussed in more detail in the Parched earth wind of fortune.

Judgement 184

• Assembly: Wisdom
• Raised By: Palladius Ravenspire
• Judgement: There is no evidence the soul resides in the heart, and through insight there is evidence that contradicts the claim that eating a heart transfers the soul. As such the claims of the Ramora family fail the test of Wisdom.
• Outcome: Upheld (164-0)

Judgement 186

• Assembly: Varushka
• Raised By: Anatolij Paukov Zorkin
• Judgement: Only fools accept hearsay as truth. We the Varushkan Assembly invite those who criticize the Iron Helm's tactics and the ability of their general to wield them to speak to those who have spent time with Alderei in Military Council, the leaders of the military units who have fought alongside the Helms and of course General Alderei herself. We invite them to speak to the people of Karov present in Anvil, many of whom petitioned Alderei directly to send her army to attack the Cold Sun threatening our homes. We invite them most of all to closely read the Civil Service reports between summits at Anvil, which quite clearly stated before the Winter Solstice that while the Iron Helms disrupted the lives of many of the barbarian Black Wind sept, the only ones targeted and killed were their leaders, not their "oldest and youngest" as Levi of the Navigators would have had the General Assembly believe (Judgement 49 Winter 385YE).
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (208-12)
• Notes: Refers to the Iron Helms, and their recent engagements in Karov and in the Barrens.

Judgement 187

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Quijano i Remora i Erigo
• Judgement: The General Assembly lauds and recognises the family Remora for sharing, disputating and interpreting - for Virtuous and especially Prosperous ends - the ancient Axou necromantia in their possession. We further encourage Synod members to seek out and learn from the family Remora.
• Outcome: Not Upheld (328-402)

Judgement 188

• Assembly: Imperial Orc
• Raised By: Bloodcrow Knott
• Judgement: When ink flows too thin, it is best thickened with blood. The slaughter of the Montanians has left the Great Forest Orcs distrustful of Imperial paper. Navarr understands this and is sealing their commitments not on paper, but their very skin. We commend Navarr for reaching their kin through mutual tradition - actions the Great Forest Orcs can understand and can trust. Actions that bring your two people ever closer. But remember what still separates you. We encourage Navarr to seek counsel from those who have walked this path before. None has been more successful than the Unshackled in melding the Way of the Empire with the traditions of Ancestors.
• Outcome: Upheld (36-0)
• Notes: Relates to the complex political situation in the Barrens, and specifically the concerns of the Great Forest Orcs as discussed in the Little mercy wind of fortune.

Judgement 189

• Assembly: Varushka
• Raised By: Zbigniew Mrakovna
• Judgement: Vicious trudniki are preying on the Ketsov who have strayed into their domain, lured by untold riches. They are monsters with the face of family but the wise know the truth. We call to shlacta and wardens to be wary of these creatures as they roam. There will come a time soon when we will have to bargain and bind these creatures to ensure Ossium's safety. Go in Virtue, act in Wisdom.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (186-10)

Judgement 190

• Assembly: Imperial Orc
• Raised By: Skywise Gralka
• Judgement: Pride reaches out through the foothills and down to the heartlands even as the snow falls. A call is made to the Imperial Orc/Unshackled nation to gather at 11:30 on the first night of the next summit. We will discuss our new language of symbols. Make choices and move one step closer to its completion. Cold Sun came to Skarsind to smother our spirit in slaughter, but it can never kill our virtue or our nation.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (56-0)

Judgement 190

• Assembly: Imperial Orc
• Raised By: Skywise Rykana
• Judgement: The orcs of Skarsind mark a monumental time in our history, as we claim a second territory in Mareave. Preachers and pilgrims, let us venture forward in virtue to seek better understanding of wof what challenges we face in this new land.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (66-0)
• Notes: Refers to the allocation of Mareave as part of the Imperial Orcs nation. Further discussion of Mareave as an Imperial territory can be found in the Into the spin wind of fortune.

Judgement 198

• Assembly: The League
• Raised By: Ortenzia di Sarvos
• Judgement: This assembly warns League citizens on the coast: foam and spittle of the furious sea has been cast on the Bay of Catazar to frutrate and ruin the Grendel. Only Vigilance and Courage can defend lives and Prosperity of the League.
• Outcome: Upheld (224-0)
• Notes: This statement of principle did not receive a Greater Majority. As such, while it has been seen by many of the priests attending Anvil, judgements that pass with a lesser majority are not widely discussed outside Anvil.

Judgement 199

• Assembly: Wintermark
• Raised By: Cynerik
• Judgement: The mystics of Ishal have left their roost to investigate better ways to guide Wintermark. The stormcrows urge the Wisdom to consider our mystic ways and the Vigilance to seek signs.
• Outcome: Upheld (80-0)

Judgement 201

• Assembly: Assembly of Nine
• Raised By: Zadkiel
• Judgement: 'It is the Empire's destiny to unite the world under the Way!" - Emperor Vesna 385YE. We the Nine believe it is imperative to support the missionary work in Asavea. We must bring the way to its people no matter the cost. In support of judgement 28.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (7-0)
• Notes: Relates to efforts to send missionaries and Wayfarers to the Asavean Archipelago, as discussed in more detail in the Parts of speech wind of fortune.

Judgement 202

• Assembly: Assembly of Nine
• Raised By: Viviane Barossa de Coeurdefer
• Judgement: Our destiny is our own. The Law of Idolatry sets out examples, but does not limit our judgement. The intent behind this is to prevent any - citizen or state - from willingly giving their agency to another entity above their own.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (7-0)
• Notes: The crime of Idolatry is defined as "Subsuming human will and destiny to any inhuman entity or force. This includes the worship, veneration or exaltation of any such being or power."

Judgement 203

• Assembly: Assembly of Nine
• Raised By: Gaelen Embercast
• Judgement: The Council of Nine directs the Silent Bell to investigate the threat that the Sovereign Dho'uala poses to Imperial citizens around the Semmerlak, and how it might be countered Virtuously.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (7-0)
• Notes: Relates to the Silent Bell, and the entity known as Dho'uala that inhabits the Semmerlak.

Judgement 207

• Assembly: The Marches
• Raised By: Peregrine Boon
• Judgement: We renounce and condemn the actions of Hugh Farrier. What he has done is wrong! Next summit, he is to be shunned by the Marches and should be stripped of his position. His plans to curse Urizen is against the sentiment of the Marches. We understand the devastation curses cause and as an act of penance, any curse performed on Urizen from a Marcher is to be followed by recompence. This mine is trapped. There is nothing left to dig.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (238-12)
• Notes: Seems to relate to the situation between the Marches and Urizen, discussed in more detail in the Sound the bells wind of fortune.

Judgement 209

• Assembly: The Marches
• Raised By: Rhubarb Ironwood
• Judgement: Threshers who pat sorcerors on the back, even when they harm rivals, are no threshers at all! Shame on those who praise Marcher sorcerors! Our courageous Linley Weaver is a fine Marcher who stood and enacted a Thresher's job greatly!
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (250-0)
• Notes: Seems to reference the ongoing support of Marcher citizens and threshers for the magicians who cursed Urizen during the Spring Equinox.

Judgement 210

• Assembly: Imperial Orc
• Raised By: Skywise Tulva
• Judgement: Let me reach out to you in Skarsind for time is short. The home of the Storm Shaman has been destroyed by the Cold Sun. We bled for our home and remember the fallen but we were not enough. An avalanche will sweep down, a storm of winter cold. Evacuate its path. Protect each other, hold to your loyalties, and be vigilant for the dangers that come.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (64-0)

Mandate

Judgement 5

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Bloodcrow Vassa
• Judgement: Thrace laid the foundation for the Imperial Orcs nation, but died before he ever saw his people build on his legacy and inspiration. We send Viviane Barossa de Coeurdefer with a dose of true liao to consecrate the Legion's Rookery in Skarsind in the name of Ambition.
• Outcome: Upheld (1992-32); Margin of 1960
• Enacted. Creates a true consecration of Ambition at Legion's Rookery in Skarsind. As detailed in the The Ambition of Thrace wind of fortune.

Judgement 49

• Assembly: Urizen
• Raised By: Lepidina
• Judgement: We welcome dialogue with the Apulians to further our collective understanding of the Way, and lift each other up in virtue. We send Lepidina with 25 doses of liao to encourage those Urizen magicians who have decided to stay to share the best of Urizen culture with the League. Let us share our values with them and make Apulian a city founded on philosophy, learning and a vision for a better future.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (238-22); Margin of 216
• Enacted. This mandate will have a slow but inexorable effect on the culture of Apulian, shaping the future of the newest City of the League. As detailed in the Blue flowers in the snow wind of fortune.

Judgement 52

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Morwenna Witheredrose
• Judgement: For our Empire to offer sanctuary only to those we find convenient is to pretend at compassion while concealing the heart of a coward. We send Brynmor Rootround with 50 doses of liao to encourage Navarr to reach out to all who call Peytaht their home, swearing to protect orc and human alike regardless of their beliefs.
• Outcome: Upheld (190-154); Margin of 36
• Not Enacted: This mandate was in competition with Judgement 56.
• Notes: See Judgement 56

Judgement 56

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Brynn Tendfallen
• Judgement: We have lived alongside the Great Forest Orcs and we consider them family. We will continue to work with them while the Navarr still live and breathe and we send Brynmor Rootround with 50 doses of liao to ask Navarr to look to their Loyalty and swear an oath to protect the Great Forest Orcs as though they were our family. Strength to the Navarr, Strength to the Great Forest Orcs
• Outcome: Upheld (252-58); Margin of 194
• Enacted. The fears of the Great Forest Orcs have been soothed. Those who have established steadings in Hercynia and Miaren will be reassured that they can continue to build lives alongside the Navarr. Some of those who still live in Therunin will remain behind, even as most of them return to the Heart of Peytaht, the bonds of friendship strengthened. As detailed in the Little mercy wind of fortune
• Notes: See Judgement 56 and Judgement 124

Judgement 70

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Halwyn Splitroot
• Judgement: Gerallt Brackensong was an inspiration to all those who take Pride in songs and stories that exalt their nation. We send Brodi Brackensong with a dose of true liao to consecrate a school at First Voice Glade in Miaren in the name of Pride.
• Outcome: Upheld (898-202); Margin of 696
• Enacted. Creates a true consecration of Pride at the ruined First Voice Glade in Miaren. As detailed in the The Pride of Gerallt Brackensong wind of fortune.

Judgement 73

• Assembly: Navarr
• Raised By: Oleander Ashwood
• Judgement: The Empty Hands march on the site of the first binding of thorns, and the birthplace of our nation. We send Oleander Ashwood with 75 doses of liao to ensure that this army doesn't desecrate this site with their presence.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (306-18); Margin of 288
• Enacted. Encourages the people of Miaren to support the Navarri who support an army against Cold Sun, providing two random herbs to every military unit that supports an army fighting the Empty Hands. As detailed in the The Deer in the Sun wind of fortune.

Judgement 74

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Grey Stone
• Judgement: Good Walder was an inspiration to the prosperous regardless of where his last resting place is found. We send Tom Appleseed with a dose of true liao to consecrate the shrine at Good Walder's Orchard in Mitwold in the name of Prosperity.
• Outcome: Upheld (1256-126); Margin of 1130
• Enacted. Creates a true consecration of Prosperity at Good Walder's Orchard in Mitwold. As detailed in the The Prosperity of Good Walder wind of fortune.

Judgement 119

• Assembly: Marcher
• Raised By: Friar John of the Mourn
• Judgement: Know your heart and what commands its devotion above all else. We send Friar John of the Mourn with 25 doses of liao to let everyone in the Mournwold know that the Tusks will always fight to keep them safe.
• Outcome: Upheld (166-20); Margin of 146
• Enacted. The Tusks will gain a bonus equivalent to a thousand additional strength whenever they are fighting in Mournwold. If Mournwold is attacked and the Tusks are not present at the start of the very next season to lead the counter-attack or defence, then the oath will have been broken. As detailed in the I already know you wind of fortune.

Judgement 122

• Assembly: Imperial Orcs
• Raised By: Firesong Kirra
• Judgement: Pride conveyed by words alone is vain boasting. We send Skywise Gralka with 25 liao to ask the septs of Skarsind to support the Library of Worth. Let us come together to find the words and symbols that speak to the worth of the whole Imperial Orc nation.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (68-0); Margin of 146
• Enacted. This relates to the creation of the Library of Worth in Skarsind. The Imperial Orcs will donate 4 wains of white granite and 8 crowns to support the commission each season for the next year. This will exhaust their capacity to support other important causes; it will be impossible to use a mandate to urge the Imperial Orcs to support another commission or similar project that needed help.

Judgement 124

• Assembly: Loyalty
• Raised By: Kellin Embercast
• Judgement: I use the power of Eyes of Loyalty to send Kellin Embercast with 25 doses of liao to support "We have lived alongside the Great Forest Orcs and we consider them family. We will continue to work with them while the Navarr still live and breathe and we send Brynmor Rootround with 50 doses of liao to ask Navarr to look to their Loyalty and swear an oath to protect the Great Forest Orcs as though they were our family. Strength to the Navarr, Strength to the Great Forest Orcs"
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (376-0); Margin of 376
• Enacted. Supports Judgement 56 with the Eyes of Loyalty.

Judgement 128

• Assembly: Imperial Orcs
• Raised By: Stiv
• Judgement: All that is worthwhile is shared with those who deserve it. We send Yerende Delk with two liao to ask the sept to provide High Chalcis with herbsheart so that they might prosper. Let us show them our peerless kinship!
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (78-0); Margin of 78
• Enacted. The Yerende will provide the Gardens of Chalcis with a small supply of herbsheart each season, raising the level of investment in herb gardens by one in Reikos providing every herb garden with one realmsroot each season. As detailed in the Standing in the sun wind of fortune.

Judgement 133

• Assembly: Vigilance
• Raised By: Lievevos van Houten van Holberg
• Judgement: We prepare for malice, but must always thwart malice before it strikes against you. We send Lievevos van Houten van Holberg with 25 liao to Spiral to urge all vigilant citizens to seek out threats and drag them into the light.
• Outcome: Upheld (186-0); Margin of 186
• Enacted. The Vigilant from across the Empire will travel to Spiral and work with pilgrims there to root out threats. As detailed in the Knocking on every door wind of fortune.

Judgement 151

• Assembly: Varushkan
• Raised By: Anatoly Vassian Tatishchev
• Judgement: Strive for excellence in that of which you are proud! We send Anatolij Paukov Zorkin with 50 doses of liao to ask Varushkans to fund the Great Hall of Fabric Arts. Let no coin go unspent.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (246-0); Margin of 246
• Enacted. The people of Varushka will provide 20 wains of white granite and 40 crowns each season to the Great Hall of Fabric Arts in Karov. As detailed in the The Deer in the Sun wind of fortune.

Judgement 156

• Assembly: Marcher
• Raised By: Larkin Otterways
• Judgement: Know your heart and what commands its devotion above all else. We send Bryce the Hare with 25 doses of liao to let everyone in Mitwold know that the Drakes will always fight to keep them safe.
• Outcome: Upheld (130-10); Margin of 120
• Enacted. The Drakes will gain a bonus equivalent to a thousand additional strength whenever they are fighting in Mitwold. If Mitwold is attacked and the Drakes are not present at the start of the very next season to lead the counter-attack or defence, then the oath will have been broken. As detailed in the I already know you wind of fortune.

Judgement 165

• Assembly: Marcher
• Raised By: Sister Meredith
• Judgement: Know your heart and what commands its devotion above all else. We send Sister Meredith with 25 doses of liao to let everyone in Upwold know that the Bounders will always call Upwold home, and they will never abandon it.
• Outcome: Upheld (140-10); Margin of 130
• Enacted: The Drakes will gain a bonus equivalent to a thousand additional strength whenever they are fighting in Mitwold. If Mitwold is attacked and the Drakes are not present at the start of the very next season to lead the counter-attack or defence, then the oath will have been broken. As detailed in the I already know you wind of fortune.

Judgement 185

• Assembly: Freeborn
• Raised By: Luca i Taziel i Riqueza
• Judgement: A spark, from family, hearth, and pyre, carried by voice on wind to kohan's fire! Arise, Burning Falcon, and blaze across the sky like a comet bright as the sun-at-night! We send Aracelis i Erigo with 50 wains of mithril and 50 doses of liao to bring everburning flames from Madruga, Segura, Kahraman, and Feroz, to inspire our soldiers with a burning passion like none ever seen before!
• Outcome: Upheld (94-0); Margin of 94
• Enacted. Over the next season, and with the aid of Janon, the quality of the Burning Falcon will change from Glorious to True Conviction. As detailed in the Various storms and saints wind of fortune.

Judgement 195

• Assembly: Freeborn
• Raised By: Val
• Judgement: A spark, from family, hearth, and pyre, carried by voice on wind to kohan's fire! Arise, Burning Falcon, and blaze across the sky like a comet bright as the sun-at-night! We send Luca i Taziel i Riqueza with 50 wains of mithril and 50 doses of liao to bring everburning flames from Madruga, Segura, Kahraman, and Feroz, to inspire our soldiers with a burning passion like none ever seen before!
• Outcome: Not Upheld (0-32)

Judgement 200

• Assembly: Nine
• Raised By: Vesna Borkovna Prochnost
• Judgement: Pride conveyed by words alone is vain boasting. We send Skywise Gralka with 25 liao to ask the septs of Skarsind to support the Library of Worth. Let us come together to find the words and symbols that speak to the worth of the whole Imperial Orc nation
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (7-0); Margin of 7
• Not Enacted. It was not possible to raise this mandate in any Assembly other than the National Assembly of the Imperial Orcs. As detailed in the The Deer in the Sun wind of fortune.

Revocation

The following judgements of revocation were raised during the summit.

Judgement 129

• Assembly: Wintermark
• Raised By: Aamu, Weir Whispering Wren
• Judgement: The Senators of Wintermark are meant to represent the needs of their people, ALL of their people. Senator Hengest Dunn for Hahnmark held the nation at spear point to get a member of his hall elected as General. Due to this, in failing to represent all of his constituents, we revoke Hengest Dunn as Senator for Hahnmark
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (220-46); Margin of 174

Judgement 161

• Assembly: Dawn
• Raised By: Alistair
• Judgement: For lack of Vigilance in her dealings in the Barrens and a lack of Pride in these ambitions. We are calling for this revocation against Lady Amicia of the Semmerlak so that she has the time to reflect on the virtue of her actions and motivations to prove herself worthy of holding a position of high office.
• Outcome: Not upheld (54-290)

Challenge

The following judgement of challenge was raised during the summit

Judgement 84

• Assembly: Urizen
• Raised By: Galene Netherwatch
• Judgement: We call Valeria, Custodian of the Claw to a Virtuous Challenge. Prosperity requires no mana left unspent, yet Valeria has not attended Anvil in some seasons, leaving the mana in the sinecure stagnant.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (204-0)
• Note: The title of Custodian of the Claw will be available to appoint at the Summer Solstice 386YE

Inquisition

The following judgements of inquisition were raised during the summit.

Judgement 32

• Assembly: Courage
• Raised By: Maarit Suvidottir
• Judgement: I call Veikko Bondforger to inquisition at Sigehold Hall, Saturday 16:00. Let them demonstrate their efforts to rebuild their chains of loyalty and the courage to follow through
• Outcome: Upheld (148-0)

Judgement 33

• Assembly: Wintermark
• Raised By: Ingrid Sigeing
• Judgement: I, Ingrid Sigeing, call Shacklebreaker Thanmir Hrafnar to inquisition, to examine his role in the creation of the Liberty Pact.
• Outcome: Upheld (30-0)

Judgement 39

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Kalina Jadqigowna Piosnkowa Prochnost
• Judgement: I call Jarrigk Orzel to inquisition, as Inquisitor of Wisdom, over his role in the needless deaths of the Vendarri sept. At 1pm at the Varushkan National Hearth, we shall see what Wisdom and what Virtue informed the Consul's decisions. Right of Witness encouraged.
• Outcome: Upheld (972-0)

Judgement 42

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Sebastiano
• Judgement: When a senator proposes a motion they must be clear that they understand, and are willing to pay, the costs involved in that decision. Thus, we call Myshki Marishka Letuchaya, Senator of Karov, to inquisition. We look forward to an explanation of their ambitions. The inquisition will take place on Saturday of the Spring Summit 386YE. At 11:30am in the Varuhskan Hearth.
• Outcome: Upheld (810-52); Margin of 758

Judgement 51

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Sofonisba Amilcara di Sarvos
• Judgement: Raine Tealeaf of Urizen has worked over the past year to undermine the reckoning between Urizen and the League, and to see Spiral returned to Urizen by fair means or foul. They have now abandoned that campaign. I call Raine Tealeaf to inquisition to discuss their pride in their past, their loyalty to their home, and their ambitions for the future; and to reckon up what they are owed and see that debt settled. Saturday of this summit, 6pm, Crimson Reaper Garrison. All welcome, especially those of Urizen and the League.
• Outcome: Upheld (770-0)

Judgement 53

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Morwenna Witheredrose
• Judgement: I have already inquisited Fintan Nighthaven. The powers of inquisition do not let me jump straight to a judgement of sanction. Please vote for this judgement to see the result of that inquisition held at 11:30pm on the Saturday of last summit.
• Outcome: Upheld (568-266); Margin of 302

Judgement 78

• Assembly: Ambition
• Raised By: Lutobor Branislavovich Glinka
• Judgement: Despise the weakness that comes from pettiness and lack of vision! We call to inquisition Alexios of Ember's Wake, to weigh their ambition in passing a declaration in Conclave telling all the realms that without the ritual Dripping Echoes of the Fen, empowered by Sadogua, the Empire is undefended: 6pm Saturday in The Shade at the top of Urizen (facing Varushka). All priests of Ambition are encouraged to attend.
• Outcome: Upheld (180-32); Margin of 148

Judgement 80

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Sebastiano
• Judgement: When Good Walder came upon a village he was pleased by those who shared their own good fortune with him in return for labour. Had they taken the food and drink from another village he would have rightly chastised them as thieves. The virtue fund exists to reward the deeds of those found worthy. It is not a coinpurse to draw on in advance of your actions. Using it as a fund to construct buildings denies the virtuous of their just rewards. In the past three years Pontus Figures has taken over 101 thrones to support buildings that should have been funded by other means. We call him to inquisition to explain these actions, and to give an accounting of where this money has gone. The inquisition will take place on Saturday of the Spring Summit 386. At 3pm in House de Gavaine.
• Outcome: Upheld (672-12); Margin of 660

Judgement 83

• Assembly: Marcher
• Raised By: Sam Wychelm
• Judgement: Brother Harvest is a dangerous idolator and sorcerer and needs to be put down before he can do further harm! I elect Lenarius Ankarien, the Imperial Inquisitor, to delve into his actions and allies.
• Outcome: Upheld (146-0)

Judgement 159

• Assembly: Vigilance
• Raised By: Brother Geoffrey Orchard
• Judgement: Come summer we will have some idea of who, if anyone, has take up the offers of Siakha and the effect that has had. Therefore I call Ibiss Briarheart, Archmage of Spring, to inquisition at 2:30pm, Saturday, Summer 386, Boundaryfolk Camp, Marches. Let us discuss how Siakha and other eternals seek undue influence over the Empire, to the detriment of virtue.
• Outcome: Upheld (116-0)

Judgement 163

• Assembly: Dawnish
• Raised By: The Fool of Glory
• Judgement: Lady Amicia of the Semmerlak, I call you to inquisition to discuss the matter of Dho'uala, the sovereign that dwells in the waters of the Semmerlak. 5:30pm, Saturday, Summer Solstice. Location to be agreed up on likely weather dependent.
• Outcome: Upheld (162-10); Margin of 152

Judgement 172

• Assembly: Dawnish
• Raised By: Allula du Besté
• Judgement: Lord Cain of House Vortekar, I call an inquisition on your pride. You sacrificed yours and your houses' pride and advocacy of the Conclave for the sake of a 4 thrones bribe. Where is Lord Cain's pride and what are his intentions for the good of the house? What stock should we take in our own pride if the heads of our house can be swayed with a few coppers. To take place at House Vortekar, next summit, Saturday 2pm.
• Outcome: Upheld (100-20); Margin of 80

Judgement 176

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Ardens of the Wanderer
• Judgement: The House of the Wanderer invites Elagabala, sword scholar and proxy Grandmaster of the Sevenfold Path, to inquisition next summit to discuss the future of the order. Elegabala has been informed and consents to the inquisition.
• Outcome: Upheld (780-0)

Judgement 183

• Assembly: Pride
• Raised By: Olyvar of Esther's Sanctum
• Judgement: When someone's soul holds the testimony Virtuous Archmage, then this must be verified. I call to inquisition Ematius Ankarien, Archmage of Winter, at a time and place to be arranged next summit as his duties demand. Show us the arete you bring to the role.
• Outcome: Upheld (134-0)

Judgement 194

• Assembly: Pride
• Raised By: Olyvar of Esther's Sanctum
• Judgement: I call to inquisition the outgoing High Bard, Protectorate Rile, to examine what they have encouraged in the music and culture in the Empire, and their outgoing collection of "Freedom" poetry. Time and place to be arranged, Summer Solstice 386YE.
• Outcome: Upheld (134-10); Margin of 124

Judgement 204

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Lenarius Ankarien
• Judgement: As Imperial Inquisitor I call Finna i Fijadoz to inquisition at the Summer summit, to answer accusations of abuse of priestly powers.
• Outcome: Automatically Upheld

Judgement 205

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Heilyn Bronwen's Rest
• Judgement: As Basilisk of the Bourse, I call Arlais Silent Tide to inquisition at 12:30 on Saturday of the Summer summit at the Silent Tide camp.
• Outcome: Automatically Upheld

Judgement 206

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Rhubarb Ironwood
• Judgement: The Arcane Inquisitor calls Edmundo, Archmage of Autumn, to examine his career, interactions and deals with eternals, and virtuous or unvirtuous conduct. If there are questions one wishes to submit, please attend. 4pm, Saturday. Hogsgrove Coppice Awning (or appropriate).
• Outcome: Automatically Upheld

Judgement 208

• Assembly: Marcher
• Raised By: Sam Wychelm
• Judgement: I call Hugh Farrier to an inquisition at the Marchers at Saturday at Equinox. In regard to his intent to fund a territory curse on Urizen land. It will take into note his position as Champion of Prosperity and thrice-celebrated hero of Virtue by the Synod.
• Outcome: Upheld (250-0)

Sanction

The following judgements of sanction were raised during the summit.

Judgement 15

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Lenarius Ankarien
• Judgement: (Penance) With regards to the Inquisition of Cassia Silkweaver, I find that their inquisition of Sagua i'Ezmara in Spring 385 was greatly flawed. Through inexperience and a desire to be thorough, Cassia collected a great deal of evidence, but put to much credence on hearsay and opinion, allowing herself to be swayed by arguments with little weight or significance. This lead to an unwarranted castigation of the then Master of the Koboldi, and ultimately Sagua losing their position. This would have been an abuse of priestly powers was I not convinced that Cassia's intentions were virtuous, even if the execution was lacking. As penance, Cassia should not undertake any further inquisitions without further consulting a Virtue Inquisitor
• Outcome: Upheld (678-138); Margin of 540

Judgement 60

• Assembly: Wintermark
• Raised By: Rafe
• Judgement: (Vindication) I vindicate Rane Shardbearer in regards to their senatorial conduct surrounding the Barrens septs. I have found them to have acted virtuously under difficult circumstances. The decisions made were forced to be done under extreme time pressure by the civil service but Rane showed wisdom in acting upon what they knew at the time, keeping legal, moral, practical and virtuous concerns in mind as they did so. They acted out of loyalty to their friends, colleagues, and allies and did so with the courage to speak in support of controversial propositions when few others would do so.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (218-0)

Judgement 71

• Assembly: Vigilance
• Raised By: Telyn Stormtree
• Judgement: (Penance) I inquisited Anthemius Netherwatch on the Saturday of the Winter Solstice summit 385YE with regards to his leading of the casting of Bright Eyes Gleam in the Depths. I found no malice in his actions, but a lack of balance in his appreciation of virtues. Too much Pride, not enough Vigilance. Indeed, I would like to call out any who claimed to warn him but did not actually act to stop the ritual. It is you who truly lack Vigilance. Inaction is a choice, just as action is. I have therefore given Anthemius a penance, to speak with Tiberius Stormspire Cascade in the next half-year, on the subject of Vigilance and who to apply it to the use of magic.
• Outcome: Not Upheld (102-112); Margin of 10

Judgement 87

• Assembly: Pride
• Raised By: Elisandre de Rondell
• Judgement: (Vindication) In the matter of the inquisition of Lady Clarice Novarion, we find that the Lady has acted with virtue.
• Outcome: Upheld (208-0)

Judgement 100

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Silas of the Cenotaph
• Judgement: (Vindication) Cyrus, Daniel, Tirza and Enoch are examples of Active, Virtuous, and efficient priests. Their methodical work to uproot, expose and end those enemies within the Empire whilst ensuring their work never disturb the houses of state from doing their job sets an example to us all. I encourage all to follow their example. Wait not for titles. DO THE VIRTUOUS WORK. Wisdom Questions All. Silas.
• Outcome: Upheld (958-10); Margin of 948

Judgement 105

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Kasjay
• Judgement: (Vindication) Aurum Nightingale has let loyalty guide all of his actions since they have turned up to Anvil. Their great loyalty has helped achieve great things in the Empire and to inspire others. They should continue to act in virtue and look to how they can let ambition drive them to greater virtue.
• Outcome: Upheld (896-130); Margin of 766

Judgement 123

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Kalina Jadwigowna Piosnkowa Prochnost
• Judgement: (Penance) On the matter of his role as a key voice in the Senate's decision to declare the Vendarri sept as barbarians, and their subsequent eradication by the Karass sept, I find Jarrigk Orzel's Wisdom insufficient. While he may not lack for other Virtues, I find in him a tendency to rely on assumption and hearsay, rather than proactively seeking relevant and factual information. Had he made the effort to seek out information and not assumed he likely would not have, for example, convinced the Senate through his testimony that declaring the Vendarri barbarians would not be the same as declaring war on them - which it categorically is. This inquisition is not for hindsight. In the moment, he acted on the information he had and I find him un-Wise but not un-Virtuous. Penance: May he carry the Hallowing of the Stormcrow. May he learn from others and seek knowledge to better serve the Empire. In a year, may he return to my hearth and be tested on what he has learned.
• Outcome: Upheld (984-10); Margin of 974

Judgement 134

• Assembly: Wintermark
• Raised By: Ingrid Sigeing
• Judgement: (Vindication) I vindicate the virtue of Shacklebreaker Thanmir Hrafnar, who acted with courage against the formidable foe of slavery in his work to form the Liberty Pact. His actions remind us of the heroism of the many acting as one, that a hero is called to great deeds over personal glory, and that the Steinr see the strengths of our fellows and urge them on to heroism.
• Outcome: Upheld (158-0)

Judgement 139

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Sebastiano
• Judgement: (Penance) Senator Myshki Marishka Letuchaya has a great deal of ambition to protect her people. However, I have great concerns about her position on the exact terms of idolatry. Whilst I do not state that her mandate would have amounted to this crime, I fear that had it passed she would have placed civil servants in danger of engaging in it. As PENANCE I instruct the senator to speak with the varied National Assemblies to understand how other nations viewed her mandate.
• Outcome: Upheld (838-144); Margin of 694

Judgement 140

• Assembly: Marcher
• Raised By: Rhubarb Ironwood
• Judgement: (Vindication) Inquisiton of Sister Meredith: She has been thoroughly questioned on matters pertaining to her views and career. Her work with the Mourn orcs and the Mournwold are outstanding, her courage admirable. But her journey, despite everything, is not over!
• Outcome: Upheld (144-0)

Judgement 141

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Sebastiano
• Judgement: (Penance) Pontius Figures certainly demonstrates virtuous ambitions to complete great works. However, his use of the virtue fund raises two areas of deep concern. 1 - His habit of turning rewarding coin into white granite while granting himself a fee of 4 crowns per wain (example). 2 - A fundamental misunderstanding of the purpose of rewarding. As penance he will explore ways to be more clear of his purpose in his judgements and how the rewarding will happen. He will be required to speak with the Virtue Assemblies within the next year to gain their input.
• Outcome: Upheld (852-124); Margin of 728

Judgement 142

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Sebastiano
• Judgement: (Penance) Pickers Goldleaf is many thing, a citizen who may be considered brash, clumsy, and headstrong. However, we do not find him greatly lacking virtue. There are questions regarding his ambition. He believes he has identified a fundamental flaw within the workings of the Imperial Senate, we challenge him to pursue a solution. As penance he will seek the counsel of ambition priests over the next summit for guidance.
• Outcome: Upheld (776-44); Margin of 732

Judgement 152

• Assembly: Dawnish
• Raised By: Linnette Alighieri
• Judgement: (Penance) Lord Bohemond de Rondell, Senator of Astolat, has been inquisited over the matter of recent Dawnish actions in the Barrens. I find he acted following his understanding of virtue. However, his understanding does present weaknesses. For this reason I request the following penance: he shall converse with me and accept guidance over relevant matters over the next 4 seasons. Within this inquisition, a lack of efficient communication between the bodies of state has also been identified, which we shall discuss further as part of his penance.
• Outcome: Upheld (234-10); Margin of 224

Judgement 162

• Assembly: Dawnish
• Raised By: The Fool of Glory
• Judgement: (Penance) Following the Inquisition of Archavion Wolfbourne as represented by his adjutant and regarding his actions in the Barrens, we gave him a Penance. For one year, he will consult with the National Assembly of Dawn at least once per season, and the Fool of Glory shall accompany him to Military Council as an observer from the Assembly.
• Outcome: Upheld (134-26); Margin of 108

Judgement 164

• Assembly: Dawnish
• Raised By: Gwendolyn de Vexille
• Judgement: (Penance) Aramis du Froste - you were called to inquisition so that you might answer for your actions as Senator for the Barrens and the impact you have had. I understand that you attempted to act in Virtue but find your understanding to be flawed. Still, I deem you worthy of support in rising in Virtue and thus I do not condemn. Rather, I offer penance: For the next 3 summits you shall seek my counsel as priest confessor at least once per summit. Together, in consultation with the Troubadours of Dawn, we will work to identify a project which may liberate and uplift those you have failed. You will raise 50T for this project.
• Outcome: Upheld (122-94); Margin of 28

Judgement 168

• Assembly: Prosperity
• Raised By: Luca i Taziel i Riqueza
• Judgement: (Vindication) In Winter 384, Khalama i Radh i Guerra and the Sails of the First Flame cast Hallow of the Green World. Prosperity was not at the heart of this ritual, but nor did it have to be. Ambition is a Virtue, and more importantly Ambition was their Virtue. The Inquisitor cannot find fault in the Virtue of their action, and wishes to commend them for the Prosperity shown in their reaction: performing Blessing of New Spring at cost for those taking advantage of the ritual's opportunity. It is all too easy to claim sweet grapes but disown sour, during Inquisition Khalama exhibited the opposite behaviour. When pressed, he was quick to carry blame for the damage wrought, but hesitate to take credit for bounties brought. This does not warrant a Penance, merely an encouragement that if there is a next time, the Coven recognise the fruits of their labour. These rituals will grow both sweet and sour fruit, neither Coven nor Empire can forget that.
• Outcome: Upheld (186-0)

Judgement 180

• Assembly: Courage
• Raised By: Maarit Suvidottir
• Judgement: (Vindication) I talked with Sarah of the Suns of Couros about the death of Enoch of Felix Watch. Sarah acted with courage throughout and counselled Enoch to improve his courage. This vigilance enabled him to face circumstances with her and others vigilantly that led to eventually to his death. May he pass swiftly through the labyrinth.
• Outcome: Upheld (132-0)

Judgement 181

• Assembly: Courage
• Raised By: Maarit Suvidottir
• Judgement: (Vindication) I inquisited Veikko Bondforger and I am satisfied by the steps he has taken to mend his bonds. He has paid weregild, contributed his loyalty to projects of the Mark. More than that he has had the courage to have hard conversations with the Assembly of Loyalty, his nation, and his friends. He has looked into the dark of his soul and faced this with courage to improve himself and rebuild his bonds.
• Outcome: Upheld (122-0)

Judgement 192

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Olyvar of Esther's Sanctum
• Judgement: (Penance) Following my inquisition of Enchanter Kym of the Twisted Rose, I find that his motivations were entirely virtuous, with great loyalty and ambition for the future of the Barrens. However he took on Autumn magic approach to a Winter magic problem - and now he has passed into the Labyrinth. This was a Conclave problem brought to the Synod - the bridge of the Sevenfold Path goes both ways!
• Outcome: Upheld (562-18); Margin of 544

Judgement 196

• Assembly: Ambition
• Raised By: Lutobor Branislavovich Glinka
• Judgement: (Penance) Alexios said they first thought of raising the declaration after hearing of Sadogua's anger, expressing some influence on their will. They were also under the impression that the ritual had failed in Kallavesa. They believed Brat Umbral Path that Dripping Echoes of the Fen would never work again - since proved untrue. Alexios acknowledges now that claiming the Empire was undefended was poorly worded. They say their actions were motivated by loyalty to the Empire. Their declaration was carelessly worded, based on falsehoods, and showed a lack of ambition by not seeking other ways to defend the Empire. Yet they do acknowledge that no eternal can be trusted. And they have committed create an arcane projection to add to the Empire's defences. Their penance is to meet with Lutobor as a priest of ambition every summit for a year, to report on progress in defending the Empire with ambition.
• Outcome: Upheld (90-20); Margin of 70

Judgement 197

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Morwenna Witheredrose
• Judgement: (Vindication) Last summit Fintan Nighthaven manifested the four word testimony "True Icon of Peace". As Inquisitor of the Way I immediately called him to an "informal" inquisition that evening. The inquisition was conducted under the light of the shield Bawnwatch, and its allowing drove me to rout whatever corruption there might have been in Fintans spirit. I found none. He has acted with utmost vigilance, routing the risk of military threats from Axos while recovering a relic of the faith. He did so without shedding a single drop of blood, and in the process secured our Empire valuable information about non imperial auras. His testimony reflects this magnificent feat. Discounting its miraculous nature simply because its wording makes us squeamish would only denigrate his success.
• Outcome: Upheld (838-58); Margin of 780

Recognition

The following judgements of recognition were raised during the summit.

Judgement 11

• Assembly: Ambition
• Raised By: Rafael Barossa d'Apulian
• Judgement: We recognise Amika Acciai, sixth child of the House of Steel, as an Exemplar of Ambition. He reached out to Rafael Barossa d'Apulian, seeking help with his goal to "engulf Asavea in a firestorm of change". Pilgrimage:Amika travelled to the Temple of the Way in Nemoria and studied there under Sumaash and Imperial priests. Benevolence: Amika turned his family estate into a safe haven for followers of the Way fleeing persecution by the Plenum. Salvation: Amika freed his family's slaves and taught them the Way. These pilgrims infiltrated other estates and spread the Way to the slaves there. Amika led the attack on the Tarquinius family estate, killing the oppressors there and giving his life for the cause. Inspiration: Amika's death inspired his cousin Alberto, who led the attack on the city of Marlien that freed all the slaves there, and started the wave of unrest that is currently crashing across Asavea.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (320-10); Margin of 310
• Notes: The recognition of Amika Acciai will be escalated to the General Assembly for evaluation at the Summer Solstice.

Judgement 19

• Assembly: Loyalty
• Raised By: Eevi of the Gadrai
• Judgement: Dogri Thulebane is an Exemplar of Loyalty. The signs are clear. Inspiration: Dogri's words inspired more than 200 fighters to stand with him in defence of Crow's Keep and Skarsind. in 385YE Spring, Dogri's story was added to Wintermark's Chronicle of Heroism as a national inspiration. Benevolence: Dogri opened Crow's Keep to all Skarsind winterfolk who did not want to leave. When the battle of Crow's Keep was lost, he ordered his followers to escape with their lives rather than lead them to their death. Miracle: Upon his death, a spontaneous aura of Loyalty manifested on the amulet he was wearing with no intervention from practitioners of Liao ceremonies. Legacy: Crow's Ridge is the region where Crow's Keep is found. After Dogri's stand, Crow's Ridge was taken by the Thule but the scars of Thulebane remain. Crow's Ridge is Dogri's legacy and for that legacy we have been granted an opportunity in 385YE Sumer to create an inspirational tomb for him, in his final resting place; the Sovevann, Kallavesa with true liao
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (473-36); Margin of 437
• Notes: The recognition of Dogri Thulebane will be escalated to the General Assembly for evaluation at the Summer Solstice.

Writ of Consecration

The following Writs of Consecration were requested during the summit.

Judgement 106

• Assembly: Pride
• Raised By: Lady Kaywenn de Orzel
• Judgement: It is the will of the Pride Assembly that a writ of consecration for an inspirational tomb, for the exemplar of Pride Ozren de Orzel, be raised to inspire pilgrims to celebrate the Pride within themselves and the Empire
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (264-20); Margin of 244

Judgement 106

• Assembly: Ambition
• Raised By: Serrusto Caeli Rezia di Tassato
• Judgement: The Assembly of Ambition seeks to consecrate the Towers of Dusk to Ambition, as an effort to restructure them after the Druj occupation, using a dose of true liao.
• Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (326-16); Margin of 310

Appointment

At the Summit, the following appointments were proposed by the Assemblies of the Synod. You can find the names of citizens who currently hold Imperial titles in the Synod here.

Judgement 1

• Assembly: Ambition
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Cardinal of Ambition
• Outcome: Viviane Barossa de Coeurdefer was appointed with 142 votes. Eska Harakkadottir received 118 votes. Ser Purslane Artorigus received 26 votes.

Judgement 2

• Assembly: Vigilance
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Cardinal of Vigilance
• Outcome: Gaelen Embercast was appointed with 174 votes. Fintan Nighthaven received 30 votes.

Judgement 3

• Assembly: Ambition
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Champion of Ambition
• Outcome: Eldrid Vestardottir was appointed with 124 votes. Lady Nimue de Rondell received 28 votes. Velika Prochnost received 10 votes.

Judgement 17

• Assembly: Loyalty
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Virtue Inquisitor of Loyalty
• Outcome: Kellin Embercast was appointed with 92 votes. Eevi of the Gadrai received 80 votes. Father Edmund received 42 votes. Ser Sable received 10 votes.

Judgement 20

• Assembly: Urizen
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Arbiter of the Four Winds
• Outcome: Athenus of the House of the Wanderer received the most votes at the time the judgement closed but the position has been abrogated by the Imperial Senate before close of voting.

Judgement 23

• Assembly: Vigilance
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Champion of Vigilance
• Outcome: Jared of the Sentinel's Tower was appointed with 70 votes. Bryce of the Hare received 44 votes. Fenrys Burning Branch received 24 votes. Keelia Scorched Pine received 12 votes. Sylver Waystone Path received 12 votes. Dryn Embercast received 0 votes.

Judgement 25

• Assembly: Nine
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Arcane Inquisitor
• Outcome: Rhubarb Ironwood was appointed with 5 votes. Bryn Tendfallen received 4 votes. Ari of the Scarlet Guard received 0 votes. Brother Geoffrey Orchard received 0 votes. Callista of the Dark Shard received 0 votes. Casimir Pakkanovic Mislova received 0 votes. Clerabela Vicente d'Apulian received 0 votes. Galene Netherwatch received 0 votes. Lutobor Branislavovich Glinka received 0 votes.

Judgement 26

• Assembly: Dawnish
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Voice of the Twin Roses
• Outcome: Noble Seri of the Twisted Rose was appointed with 60 votes. Earl Ailsa Tamerlaine received 30 votes. Hieronyus Dowland received 20 votes.

Judgement 27

• Assembly: Nine
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the High Bard of the Empire
• Outcome: Malcón i Dyrelnos i Erigo was appointed with 5 votes. Tarik of Ashenhall received 3 votes. Burnlin Drumheart received 0 votes. Jymi Handaxe received 0 votes. Kish of the Flame Beneath the Earth received 0 votes. Mercy Summermuse received 0 votes. Sofonisba Amicara di Sarvos received 0 votes.

Judgement 29

• Assembly: Wintermark
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Speaker of the Crows
• Outcome: Ingrid Sigeing was appointed with 220 votes.

Judgement 30

• Assembly: Pride
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Virtue Inquisitor of Pride
• Outcome: Olyvar of Esther's Sanctum was appointed with 176 votes. Kazimir Syrota Molenav received 10 votes.

Judgement 57

• Assembly: Courage
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Guardian of Britta's Memorial
• Outcome: Neala Blackhawk was appointed with 66 votes.

Judgement 58

• Assembly: Highborn
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Lepidean Librarian
• Outcome: Hazelelponi of the Shattered Tower was appointed with 224 votes.

Judgement 63

• Assembly: Prosperity
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Champion of Prosperity
• Outcome: Hugh Farrier was appointed with 200 votes.

Judgement 94

• Assembly: Nine
• Raised By: Tribune
• Judgement: Appointment of the Auditor of Senatorial Accountability
• Outcome: Vauras 'Prosperity's Forge' Korppitkotka was appointed with 6 votes. Algernon Berinore received 2 votes. Jules von Holberg received 0 votes.

Rewarding

The following judgements of rewarding were sought during the summit.

Judgement 6

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Pontus Figures
• Judgement: Dialagos has presented the Empire with the chance to construct Prosperous Counting Houses that will increase the income to the virtue fund each season. This provides us an opportunity to invest now for benefits in perpetuity. Each house requires 5 White Granite, 5 Weirwood, and 30 crowns. We propose the virtue fund should take advantage and would ask for funds to acquire the needed resource to construct the house with the highest return at the point sufficient material has been gathered (currently Tassato for 16 crowns/season)> we seek the assemblies approval to purchase 2 wains of weirwood using 10 Thrones and 0 Crowns. Should this pass, further requests will be placed until the full balance of material is acquired. Last summit 2 wains were purchased for this endeavour.
• Outcome: Upheld (578-548); Margin of 30
• Notes: Refers to the counting house project proposed by Dialagos of Urizen.

Judgement 13

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Teleri Thornweaver
• Judgement: To reward Brodi Brackensong with one dose of true liao to consecrate an inspirational location for Gerallt Brackensong, exemplar of Pride. Actual location to be decided as part of separate mandate.
• Outcome: Upheld (630-444); Margin of 186

Judgement 18

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Constanza i Kalamar i Guerra
• Judgement: For his continued work as the Friar of Honour's Rest in aiding the countless ghosts of the Mournwold move on to the next part of their spiritual journey, we reward Friar John of the Mourn 40 thrones. This should allow for the purchase of materials necessary for the construction of the Orchard of the Watch; a memorial for those that died during the liberation of the Mournwold. This will allow the souls to cease lingering, put an end to the territory's haunting, and create a site of remembrance for the survivors of this blood portion of Imperial history. The spirits of myriad heroes still haunt the ruins of Overton. The fear that their sacrifice will not be remembered keeps them from their rest. Priests of the Empire; let the virtue fund reward these virtuous souls for their service and sacrifice.
• Outcome: Upheld (782-364); Margin of 418

Judgement 24

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Grogfear Kraaida
• Judgement: For ten years Osgar Boarsnout has fought for the Empire with Courage and Loyalty. Starting as a simple footsoldier, Osgar was promoted to captain and then handpicked by Reidarr Bloodletter as their replacement as commander of the Heart of the Mark. For his unyielding Loyalty, Courage and Wisdom protecting the people of the Empire, the Synod awards Osgar 10 thrones. One for each year of service.
• Outcome: Not Upheld (418-446); Margin of 28

Judgement 35

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Dolce di Sarvos
• Judgement: The Synod rewards Laurencio di Sarvos with Seven Thrones for his work supporting newcomers to Anvil, and in particular or the creation of the 'Deed of Debut'. The Deed of Debut is a document available to newcomers to Anvil that allows them to take advantage of a range of special offers provided by a variety of high-quality vendors in the League, including food, drink, archery, cicisbeos and more. This supports their introduction to Anvil, helps their money go further and supports the businesses and traders at Anvil. This rewarding could help spread this initiative to more vendors, more nations and support even more people newly arrived at Anvil.
• Outcome: Upheld (526-80); Margin of 446

Judgement 36

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Jules von Holberg
• Judgement: Too often the labour and toil of Artisans goes uncelebrated and is taken for granted, yet through their efforts are the heros of the Empire are better protected and better able to fight for the Empire and show the Way. So I call on the Synod to reward Marcus von Temeschwar, lone artisans of the celebrated Sea Wolves, with Fifty Crowns for tirelessly working to strengthen and protect those to whom he is loyal.
• Outcome: Not Upheld (378-534); Margin of 156

Judgement 37

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: 'Shacklebreaker' Thanmir Hrafnar
• Judgement: To reward Zadkiel de Couerdefer the sum of 20 thrones for their work to create a means of communication with the hitherto unknown nation of the Elakar. Zadkiel showed unfailing Pride in their own abilities and used these to acquire donations from citizens totalling 100 thrones used to acquire 40 rings of ilium needed to establish this communication. Zadkiel intends to use this rewarding to repay some of these donations.
• Outcome: Upheld (606-304); Margin of 302

Judgement 99

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Sibling Amos of Tian's Return
• Judgement: Sibling Nekoda of the Shattered Tower has worked tirelessly to help new siblings at Anvil find their place within our great Empire - helping them achieve their ambitions with coins & liao from their own pocket. We call on the Assembly to reward them with 2 thrones so they can continue to inspire the next generation of virtuous heroes.
• Outcome: Upheld (850-246); Margin of 604

Judgement 102

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Luciana Valesi
• Judgement: Thanmir Hrafnar was instrumental in funding efforts to open communications, raising over 100T to make this diplomatic outreach possible. He displayed great Prosperity in making this mission possible, fuelled by great Pride in our Empire. We request 10 thrones from the virtue fund to reward these efforts.
• Outcome: Upheld (388-144); Margin of 244

Judgement 104

• Assembly: General
• Raised By: Aristeia Starchaser
• Judgement: For the past four seasons Serenus Starsong and the coven of Storm's End have used their own mana to fund the APs and rituals that have revealed to us the names of the stars - Oak, Web, Phoenix, and Great Wyrm. We award Serenus 20 thrones from the Virtue Fund in recompense with Pride and recognition of their Ambitions.
• Outcome: Upheld (478-432); Margin of 46

The Virtue Fund

The following represents the Virtue Fund of the Synod:

Starting Value	3 Rings
Donation	1 Crown	Donation by Tom Appleseed.
Donation	1 Crown, 7 Rings	Donation by Crassus, for the Sand Fishers.
Donation	1 Crown, 16 Rings	Donation by the Secretary General of the Civil Service from the sale of writing implements.
Donation	5 Rings	Donation by Lysimachus.
Donation	11 Thrones, 4 Crowns	Donation by an anonymous individual on behalf of "A Prosperous Consortium".
Donation	1 Crown	Donation by Berith Martel.
Donation	5 Rings	Donation by Alistair.
Donation	1 Crown	Donation by Maelfaisance Remys.
Income	85 Thrones	The price paid in the Bourse Auction for the dose of True Liao.
Donation	2 Rings	Donation by Finna.
Donation	1 Crown	Donation by Tom Appleseed.
Rewarding	7 Thrones	Rewarding to Dolce di Sarvos following Judgement 35 being upheld (a margin of 446).
Rewarding	40 Thrones	Rewarding to Constanza i Kalamar i Guerra following Judgement 18 being upheld (a margin of 418).
Rewarding	20 Thrones	Rewarding to Thanmir "Shacklebreaker" Hrafnar following Judgement 37 being upheld (a margin of 302).
Rewarding	10 Thrones	Rewarding to Luciana Valesi following Judgement 102 being upheld (a margin of 244).
Rewarding	10 Thrones	Rewarding to Pontus Figures following Judgement 6 being upheld (a margin of 30).
Donation	2 Crown, 12 Rings	Donation by the Secretary General of the Civil Service from the sale of writing implements.
Donation	1 Throne	Donation by Luca and a Marcher friend.
Donation	1 Crown	Donation by Veikko Bondforger.
Donation	1 Crown, 5 Rings	Donation by Belakov Zakharovich Prochnost.
Donation	1 Crown	Donation by Tom Appleseed.
Donation	1 Ring	Donation by Lysimachus.
Rewarding	2 Thrones	Rewarding to Amos following Judgement 99 being upheld (a margin of 604).
Rewarding	10 Thrones, 1 Crown, 16 Rings	Rewarding to Aristeia Starchaser following Judgement 104 being upheld (a margin of 46) - insufficient funds for full rewarding.
Donation	4 Crowns, 2 Rings	Donation by the Secretary General of the Civil Service from the sale of writing implements.
Closing Value	4 Crowns, 2 Rings

Doses of True Liao

Five doses of True Liao were disbursed this summit:

• One dose to Vesna Borkovna Prochnost as the Throne
• One dose in connection to the Lepidean University to Teleri Thornweaver via Judgement 13
• One dose to Idris Eternal by purchase in the Public Auction
• One dose to Halwyn Splitroot by decision of the Gatekeepers
• One dose to Clytemnestra of the House of the Wanderer by decision of the Gatekeepers

Special Considerations

The following considerations should be borne in mind when bringing judgements before the Imperial Synod during the Spring Equinox.

Assembly	Consideration	Link	Duration
All Assemblies	Statements that prioritise the greater good over personal loyalties are less effective.	Eyes of Loyalty	Ongoing
All Assemblies	Statements that try to compel Loyalty will fail.	Eyes of Loyalty	Ongoing
All Assemblies	Revocations and Excommunications for disloyalty to the nation or Empire risk causing dissent.	Eyes of Loyalty	Ongoing
All Assemblies	Any mandate that does not pass with a greater majority will have limited or no effect on Urizen or Varushka. It is not impossible that a mandate might lead to a response in one of the two nations, but it won't lead to any immediate consequences for the people of the nation.	Urizen Link, Varushka Link.	Ongoing

Alternative Mandates

Prior to the summit, the following alternative mandates were proposed by members of the Synod.

Member	Link to mandate	Notes
Corey Wayfarer	Little mercy
Morwenna Witheredrose	Little mercy
Nathair Autumngale	The Deer in the Sun