382YE Winter Solstice Synod judgements

Ninety-three judgements were raised by the members of the Imperial Synod

Overview

During the Winter Solstice 382YE Summit, the Imperial Synod raised 93 judgements.

Change of doctrine

No change of doctrine was proposed during the Winter Solstice summit.

Veto

The veto was not sought during the Winter Solstice 382YE.

Statement of principle

The following statements of principle were presented to the assemblies of the Imperial Synod. Fifteen of these statements achieved a Greater Majority, meaning they will be distributed to appropriate assemblies.

Judgement 5

Assembly: General
Raised By: Lev Unbound
Judgement: Exemplars provide inspiration by their Virtuous deeds. Recognition of such persons by the Synod is not an exaltation, we must not worship or venerate them. Rather we should look to their lives and deeds and seek inspiring examples of Virtue applied in practice. Seeking inspiration in virtuous deeds of an Exemplar is not subsuming our will or our destiny.
Outcome: Upheld (1153 - 210)

Judgement 16

Assembly: Pride Virtue
Raised By: Rafael Barossa di Tassato
Judgement: We join our voices with Veikko Bondforger to condemn Almodin Oktístis, the "Asavean Architect". His inclusion of blasphemous and idolatrous iconography in large scale constructions is an affront to Imperial Pride, which we ought to proclaim in every aspect of our lives.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (262 - 0)

Judgement 21

Assembly: Urizen National
Raised By: Alcuin of the Auric Horizon
Judgement: Following a national debate on the subject it is the position of Urizen that: any individual dedicated to the principles of Urizen who wishes to join the nation should be considered be they human or orc.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (89 - 0)

Judgement 27

Assembly: General
Raised By: Cimeies of Felix's Watch
Judgement: The Imperial Synod recognises that orcs can have virtue but to exalt them as exemplars is to venerate an inhuman soul and thus idolatry. Exemplars are on the path to paragonhood and should be exalted as inspirations to those who come after them. We call for virtuous orcs to be referred to as such rather than exemplars.
Outcome: Not Upheld (365 - 951)

Judgement 35

Assembly: Way Virtue
Raised By: Hazelelponi of the Shattered Tower
Judgement: The Way Assembly recognises that the humans that travel with the Great Forest orcs are people who have been entrapped by the false virtue of Freedom. To do nothing to address this, to simply shun them would be to ignore the principles of Ambition, Courage, and Vigilance. The Assembly calls upon priests of the Empire to encourage civilians to be guarded against their heretical beliefs, but welcoming to them as people and offer them hospitality, where we will find means to bring them to Salvation, bringing the back into the Way and the Empire. The Way Assembly calls for a citizen to be nominated to take this message and the inspiration that virtue brings over the coming seasons.
Outcome: Upheld (83 - 0)

Judgement 39

Assembly: General
Raised By: Martin Orchard
Judgement: We hold that Inquisition is an essential part of the Synod. It is the means by which we uncover truth. It is the means by which we exonerate and laud those who deserve it, and we do so in public. It is the means by which we challenge those unvirtuous who threaten the souls of all Imperial citizens. it is vital that due process of Inquisition be respected and supported by Synod. A judgement of Sanction should only be raised following an Inquisition, that priests may bear witness to the truth. Support your inquisitors.
Outcome: Upheld (684 - 17)

Judgement 41

Assembly: Urizen National
Raised By: Galene Netherwatch
Judgement: We recognise and thank the Generals of the League, Highguard, and Varushka for their Loyalty to Urizen in this time of need.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (78 - 0)

Judgement 43

Assembly: General
Raised By: Medea Ruth
Judgement: Medea Ruth's dog is a loyal and virtuous creature. Dog-ri Druj-bone is a highly trained assistant field physick. He has saved many Imperial lives by aiding Medea Ruth in finding and treating and evacuating patients in the face of the Druj invasion of Urizen. The dog was recently injured in defending Medea Ruth from Druj. The dog works tirelessly to his utmost to aid Medea Ruth. We recognise the dog's Loyalty. Virtuous dog.
Outcome: Not Upheld (143 - 863)

Judgement 44

Assembly: General
Raised By: Saavi Anaasdottir
Judgement: Slavery is abhorrent and should be stamped out. No slave can truly follow virtue as their will is not their own - they cannot be Proud, Ambitious, or Loyal if they are bought and sold. An opportunity has arisen to strike the Grendel in Mareave and free up to 2000 slaves. The independent captains who take this action should be commended for their virtue.
Outcome: Upheld (823 - 294)

Judgement 45

Assembly: General
Raised By: Zastyt the Feeder
Judgement: The synod urges the virtuous citizens of the Empire to tear down all idolatrous statues and show Sumaah that we are true pilgrims of the Way.
Outcome: Upheld (566 - 355)

Judgement 46

Assembly: Dawn National
Raised By: Ser Ancel Watcher
Judgement: We are the glorious heart of the Empire and the fire of our virtue is warmth to our friends and ruin to our enemies. We urge troubadours to venture forth to Ossium to bring tales of virtue and glory to burn away the lingering dread imposed by the verminous Druj. "Troubadours to Ossium go / Let tales of virtue and glory grow / And in the light of Dawn they'll know / The Way now through this land shall flow."
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (126 - 0)

Judgement 49

Assembly: Courage Virtue
Raised By: Clarice Novarion
Judgement: The path of courage tells us to despise cowardice, not to inspire it. The use of torture, and cruel tactics, is predicated on inspiring terror and cowardice in the victim and in all who witness such atrocity. The assembly of Courage condemns the use of such tactics.
Outcome: Upheld (128 - 20)

Judgement 50

Assembly: General
Raised By: Gilah of the Chantry
Judgement: Pilgrims visiting the shrine of the exemplar Zemress at Calvos Sound in the Brass Coast who are dedicated to the Way should be allowed to conduct their pilgrimage in safety regardless of their country of origin.
Outcome: Upheld (1115 - 0)

Judgement 51

Assembly: Prosperity Virtue
Raised By: Lilith of the Chantry
Judgement: Pilgrims visiting the shrine of the exemplar Zemress at Calvos Sound in the Brass Coast who are dedicated to the Way should be allowed to conduct their pilgrimage in safety, regardless of their country of origin.
Outcome: Upheld (76 - 0)

Judgement 53

Assembly: Highguard National
Raised By: Lina of Felix's Watch
Judgement: The Highguard Assembly urge those of all nations who are questioning their beliefs to turn to discussion with the Grey Pilgrims, not those of Foreign Nations or Idolatrous or Heretical beliefs.
Outcome: Upheld (392 - 40)

Judgement 59

Assembly: Highguard National
Raised By: Mechior of Adina's Charge
Judgement: Courage teaches us to despise that which leads to weakness and inaction. Pride teaches us to inspire others to greatness. Torture tears others down. Torture inspires fear and inaction. Our actions affect not only our own virtue but that of everyone we meet and who hear our stories. Torture is antithetical to the virtues of Pride and Courage and thus we condemn it.
Outcome: Upheld (204 - 80)

Judgement 62

Assembly: Brass Coast National
Raised By: Mazo i Zabala i Erigo
Judgement: Pilgrims visiting the shrine of the exemplar Zemress at Calvos Sound in the Brass Coast who are dedicated to the Way should be allowed to conduct their pilgrimage in safety regardless of their country of origin.
Outcome: Upheld (88 - 0)

Judgement 63

Assembly: Urizen National
Raised By: Calpurnia of the Scarlet Guard
Judgement: To support the sending of a message to every Urizeni via an arcane projection so that a promise will reach those held captive by the Druj in Morrow and Zenith that the Empire has not forgotten them and is coming to free them, to give them Pride and Courage not to seek Kaela's Boon unnecessarily unless facing imminent torture and death.
Outcome: Upheld (60 - 19)

Judgement 65

Assembly: Varushka National
Raised By: Nisha Strascovitch
Judgement: People of Varushka; the Eternal Shafts of Time are held by Tomasz Strascovitch. The Night Quarry is held by Tomislav Strascovitch. The Hunt of Alderei the Fair is held by Bors. The Granites of Veltsgorsk are held by Vitaly Dukov. The Gift of the Dwindling Star is held by Pavel Novak. The Overseer of the Western Trade Route is held by Borys Strascovitch. All traditional Varushkan bourse seats are in Varushkan hands. In pride rejoice in the achievement of our Ambition.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (106 - 0)

Judgement 67

Assembly: Marches National
Raised By: Friar John of the Mourn
Judgement: We, the people of the Marches, take great Pride in the vast bounty of our land. This land is kept ours by the armies that defend it. Many of these soldiers serve with the Ambition that they can own their own farms. We encourage the farm owners of the Marches to thank the soldiers who rest on leave in our lands. One night of food and rest a week, so that they may know what they fight for. An army marches on its stomach, and the Marchers are the ones to bring the bread.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (102 - 0)

Judgement 68

Assembly: Varushka National
Raised By: Amvis Juhan Menkovich
Judgement: Ossium was conquered by the Empire. Although Varushka has been granted the role of managing the land we welcome the troubadours of Dawn led by Ancel Watcher in their glorious mission to cleanse the land of false virtue.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (106 - 0)

Judgement 69

Assembly: Courage Virtue
Raised By: Luis i Guerra
Judgement: The Courage assembly encourages priests to accompany Imperial Armies into Ossium with liao to remove the fear auras from the territory.
Outcome: Upheld (128 - 0)

Judgement 70

Assembly: Courage Virtue
Raised By: Leonora van Holberg
Judgement: The Courage assembly posthumously recognises the tireless and unstinting work of Levitia of Endsmeet (formerly Echostorm) of Urizen who strove always to support the Assembly's work.
Outcome: Upheld (128 - 0)

Judgement 71

Assembly: Courage Virtue
Raised By: Nina of Cantiarch's Hold
Judgement: The Courage assembly nominates Melchior Adina's Charge to bear for the next year the artefact spear "Oathkeeper" given to the Empress by the artisan Tom of Upwold.
Outcome: Upheld (108 - 0)

Judgement 73

Assembly: Marches National
Raised By: Friar William
Judgement: We implore all members of the Marches to be ever watchful and vigilant. The Marches is in a prosperous time and it is our belief the Marches should not grow complacent. The Marches have always known their lands and our folk are good at beating the bounds be the threats vermin or Jotun.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (102 - 0)

Judgement 75

Assembly: League National
Raised By: Eyrbia Melampus de Tassato
Judgement: This assembly endorses the Witches' Ball Event and encourages all League citizens to assist in preparation however they can and participate with enthusiasm. This assembly approves that the Witches' ball will help forge bonds of Loyalty throughout the League and across the Empire, affecting all social ties, be they business, marriage, or friendship.
Outcome: Upheld (96 - 10)

Judgement 78

Assembly: Varushka National
Raised By: Yevanshka Nicolaiova
Judgement: We the Varushan National assembly recognise the virtue of all citizens of the Empire who provided the liao needed to fulfil mandate 66 particularly: Belakov, Wolf of Karsk; Father Nikolovich Drakov; Nisha Stracovich; Anastasia of the Sovereign's Head; Atla of the Imperial Orcs; Galene Netherwarch of Urizen; Mal Lassel Scechous of Dawn.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (114 - 0)

Judgement 79

Assembly: Imperial Orc National
Raised By: Bloodcrow Losak
Judgement: The Imperial Orc national assembly invite the orcs of the Mournwold to share accounts of their beliefs with the Synod so that we may better understand them, and sends Bloodcrow Losak to seek out such accounts of thrall beliefs and evidence regarding them.
Outcome: Upheld (33 - 17)

Judgement 80

Assembly: General
Raised By: Beodun "Warcrow" Snowlock
Judgement: In recognition of the exemplary conduct of Severin von Holberg, I put it to the Synod that not only has he inspired us to work together, but has bettered our understanding of the Way like no-one since Britta's death.
Outcome: Not Upheld (301 - 327)

Judgement 82

Assembly: General
Raised By: Goran Sokolov Zaytsev
Judgement: The newly conquered territory of Ossium has been awarded to Varushka, yet as it is one of the first newly attained territories, it does not have any infrastructure. As it is a territory of the Empire, we wish to raise support for any future acquisitions that will help shape it into a virtuous territory of the Empire.
Outcome: Upheld (561 - 80)

Judgement 86

Assembly: Brass Coast National
Raised By: Constanza i Kalamar i Guerra
Judgement: Now that Freeborn citizens can choose their tribe, now more than ever we should affirm our Pride in the deep ties that bind us as a nation. We offer hospitality, care, and support in Loyalty to those we consider family, thus we encourage all citizens to extend those same courtesies to our countrymen refugees. Indeed, any of us might find ourselves in such need. Investment in refugees is important for the Prosperity of the whole nation.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (98 - 0; Primacy)

Judgement 87

Assembly: Nine
Raised By: Hywel Summer Crow
Judgement: The Assembly of Nine invites the cities of Axos to send one or more priests to Anvil in the Spring of 383YE to discuss our respective religions and further mutual understanding.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (8 - 0)

Judgement 88

Assembly: Nine
Raised By: Viviane de Courdefer
Judgement: We the Nine strongly support the potential building of the Lepidean Library, on the absolute condition that the added dose of true liao is given only to the Gatekeepers to disburse.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (7 - 1)

Judgement 89

Assembly: Nine
Raised By: Onan of the Chantry
Judgement: The Assembly of Nine wish to register their congratulations on the progress of the Liberty Pact. We commend the work of: Eska Crowspeaker; Ianthe of the Suns of Couros; Thanmir Hrafnar; Atte Arrowtongue; and the Ambassadors. We reaffirm that slavery is abhorrent.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (8 - 0)

Judgement 90

Assembly: Nine
Raised By: Astrid Fjellrevening Rezia di Tassato
Judgement: The Assembly of Nine strongly condemn the reverence of eternals, in particular the building of idolatrous statues in places of virtue - such as the suggestion of building statues to Janon within Laroc cathedral.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (8 - 0)

Judgement 91

Assembly: Nine
Raised By: Veikko Bondforger
Judgement: The Assembly of Nine ask the Silent Bell to investigate if anyone of the Empire is trading liao with the Iron Confederacy.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (8 - 0)

Judgement 92

Assembly: Marches National
Raised By: Bethany
Judgement: Yes, we know the vates (they're kind of like Navarr Landskeepers) cast Rivers Run Red. They did it against the vallorn, what traps folks' souls. It were done with the consent of the people of that land, and they turned themselves in right away - no-one did this lightly. Conclave continues to support its Interdiction.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (92 - 0; Primacy)

Mandate

The following mandates were passed during the Winter Solstice. Where there are competing mandates, the one that passes with the largest margin is successful and all other competing mandates are considered to have failed.

Judgement 3

Assembly: Dawn National
Raised By: Ranae de Rondell
Judgement: The green forest of Brocéliande is a wilderness like few others; now the vallorn that lies at its heart rises against our friends among the Navarr. The opportunity for glory here cannot be ignored; nor should the people of Semmerholm and Astolat ignore the sacrifices the Navarr have made to protect them against the malign force of the power that dwells there. The Dawn assembly sends Ranae de Rondell with 50 doses of liao to encourage knights and witches to offer their aid to the Navarr fighting to stem the green tide of the vallorn. Let knights-errant and questing knights alike face the challenge of the dark forest, and show the abhorrent power of the vallorn the might of Dawnish steel!
Outcome: Upheld (102 - 0). Ranae de Rondell provided 50 doses of liao to enact this mandate after the Winter Solstice 382YE.
Notes: The opportunity is detailed here

Judgement 4

Assembly:General
Raised By: Eska Crowspeaker
Judgement: The Way binds us together, guiding all citizens on a virtuous path. We send Eska Crowspeaker with 50 liao to spread the Way to those we have rescued from Dubhtraig to allow them to find a place for themselves in the Empire.
Outcome: Upheld (1388 - 36). Eska Crowspeaker provided 50 doses of liao to enact this mandate after the Winter Solstice 382YE.
Notes: The opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 8

Assembly: General
Raised By: Erasmo di Tassato
Jugement: The Way was founded in Bastion, and the Sumaah were among the first to follow in our footsteps. We are not tyrants however; we do not seek to chain those who accept the truth of the Way to a single dogma. The Imperial Synod acknowledges Timoj as the equal of Bastion, and the Sumaah Houses of Virtue as equal to the Imperial Senate. Equal yet separate; we seek no dominance over them but likewise grant them no authority over those pilgrims who look to Bastion for guidance. We may be in opposition, but we are not enemies, and may gain as much together by cooperation as we do alone through ambitious pursuit of the truth. We send Erasmo di Tassato with 150 doses of liao to bring this message to the people of Sumaah, and the world.
Outcome: Not Upheld (274 - 837)
Notes: The opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 9

Assembly: General
Raised By: Rafe
Judgement: All members of the Synod have a duty to represent their congregations. Those who are neither raising judgements in pursuit of their goals, nor voting in support of their understanding of Virtue, shame themselves. We send Rafe with 100 doses of liao to urge any priest in the Empire who does not make full use of their powers to take up arms and lead their congregations in heroic battle.
Outcome: Upheld (1006 - 204). Rafe provided 100 doses of liao to enact this mandate after the Winter Solstice 382YE.
Notes: The opportunity is detailed here. This judgement is similar to Judgement 10, but the two are not in competition. If both are enacted, however, their effects are not cumulative.

Judgement 10

Assembly: Wintermark National
Raised By: Severi Jarlmarison
Judgement: Those Winterfolk who are members of the Synod have a duty to represent their congregations. Those who are neither raising judgements in pursuit of their goals, nor voting in support of their understanding of Virtue, shame themselves. We send Severi Jarlmarison with 50 doses of liao to urge any priest of Wintermark who does not make full us of their powers to take up arms and lead their congregations in heroic battle.
Outcome: Upheld (167 - 25)
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here. This judgement is similar to Judgement 9, but the two are not in competition. If both are enacted, however, their effects are not cumulative.

Judgement 11

Assembly: General
Raised By: Solas
Judgement: The Way of Virtue is an enlightened faith; while we have Pride in its roots in Bastion, the Highborn discovery of True Liao, and the understanding this brought us, the true heart of the Way is anywhere discoveries are being made and understanding realised. Such events can happen anywhere and are not bound to any individual location in the Empire, Sumaah, or anywhere else. True pilgrims of the way, those who seek to understand and thus pursue Virtue, should challenge and combine their experiences and understanding so that the resulting faith is built on the strongest possible foundations. We send Solas with 150 doses of liao to bring this message to the people of Sumaah, and the world.
Outcome: Not upheld (405 - 661)
Notes: The opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 13

Assembly: General
Raised By: Bartimaeus
Judgement: The virtuous build up their fellows, and take pride in their people. Rather than looking to line their own pockets, Imperial citizens should seek ways to strengthen their own nations - and by doing so strengthen the Empire as a whole. We send Bartimaeus with 75 liao to urge Imperial citizens to consider how best the bounty of their nations might be used for the benefit of their people.
Outcome: Upheld (879 - 276). Bartimaeus provided 75 doses of liao to enact this mandate after the Winter Solstice 382YE.
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 14

Assembly: General
Raised By: Ephron of Adina's Charge
Judgement: The Way was founded in Bastion and the Sumaah follow in our footsteps. But the Proud seek to raise others up not cast them down. The Imperial Synod issues a challenge: if the Houses of Virtue wish the world to look to them for guidance, they must prove their claim. Send us not a trickle of missionaries but a flood. Let the vision of the Way that shines the brightest inspire the faithful. The Imperial Synod still leads the Virtuous and shall prevail. We send Ephron of Adina's Charge with 50 liao.
Outcome: Not Upheld (548 - 549)
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 18

Assembly: Highguard National
Raised By: Yarona of the Chantry
Judgement: The purpose of our Pilgrimage is to save souls; certainly those who have fallen to the Vallorn, but also those who are in danger of being lost to false beliefs. We the Highborn Assembly acknowledge that no citizen follows the Way perfectly. We all have room to grow, and faults to address. We send Lilith of the Chantry with 25 liao to urge the Grey Pilgrims to act as guides for all the human nations of this great Empire. As they walk the trods in the years to come, let there be no dark corner into which they cannot shine the light of Virtue.
Outcome: Upheld (410 - 192)
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 20

Assembly: General
Raised By: Jorma Steelhail
Judgement: The Way was founded in Bastion, and the Sumaah were among the first to follow in our footsteps. For so long Bastion has been a single light in sea of savagery and ignorance - the Imperial Synod is heartened to learn there are now two with Bastion's counterpart in Timoj. Rather than seek division through political pettiness, the Imperial Synod has a grander vision and so sends Jorma Steelhail with 150 doses of Liao to urge the citizens of the Empire and the Sumaah Republic to seek common ground and focus on our shared Ambition in spreading the Way to the world.
Outcome: Upheld (897 - 274). Jorma Steelhail provided 150 doses of liao to enact this mandate after the Winter Solstice 382YE.
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 22

Assembly: Highguard National
Raised By: Josephine of Adina's Charge
Judgement: The monstrous infestation that is the Vallorn is a danger beyond any other that now faces us. There is no sacrifice too great that we cannot meet it to defeat this terror. The walking of the trods will weaken the vallorn, but we must not be blind to the danger it poses to humanity. The time has come to raise sword and brand against it in defence of our allies - and to strike at the horror in Brocéliande before it becomes a threat to our own people. We send Hazelelponi of the Shattered Tower with 50 doses of liao to urge the vigilant faithful of Highguard to aid the Navarr in the defence of Brocéliande.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (514 - 0). Hazelelponi provided 50 doses of liao to enact this mandate after the Winter Solstice 382YE.
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 24

Assembly: Prosperity Virtue
Raised By: Edna of the Chantry
Judgement: As Edna has declared, the building of the Cinderpath Exchange is a virtuous endeavour that both increases the Prosperity of the Empire as a whole, and ensures that those who sell white granite receive a fair and virtuous reward for their labours. We send Edna with 100 doses of liao to urge those Prosperous citizens who have white granite to refrain from auctioning it through the Bourse Auction at Anvil until such time as the Cinderpath Exchange is completed.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (160 - 14). Sister Edna of the Chantry provided 100 dose of liao to enact this mandate after the Winter Solstice 382YE.
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 25

Assembly: Navarr National
Raised By: Corey Wayfarer
Judgement: The Empire is beset on all fronts; sacrifices must be made. Brocéliande will not be one of those. The Navarr national assembly sends Corey Wayfarer with 25 doses of liao to urge the people of the steadings and stridings of Brocéliande to find the Courage in their hearts to take up arms against our ancient enemy and stand firm in the face of such horror. The Navarr are coming to aid you, remain firm till we arrive, we will hold it back.
Outcome: Withdrawn at the request of the raising priest. When withdrawn there were 76 votes in favour and 0 against.
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 26

Assembly: Highguard National
Raised By: Dinah of Jeremiah's Welcome
Judgement: Highguard were those who founded The Way and first spread it to the peoples of the Empire's nations. They have now shown their Loyalty in kind for this great enlightenment Highguard gave to them, and it is time to spread The Way further afield through the people of foreign nations. We send Able of the Shattered Tower with 25 liao to urge the grey pilgrims to convert traveling foreigners to The Way, so that they may go back to their lands and pass on the truth.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (511 - 25) Able of the Shattered Tower provided 25 doses of liao to enact this mandate after the Winter Solstice 382YE.
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 31

Assembly: Highguard National
Raised By: Raziel of the Shattered Tower
Judgement: As Bartimaeus has already vouchsafed, virtuous people set prices for things which are fair, and buy and sell them accordingly. The Senate disagrees; it denies the virtue of engaging in trade in a virtuous manner. We send Raziel of the Shattered Tower with 25 doses of liao to urge those Highborn citizens in possession of white granite to refuse to deal with the greed embodied by the Bourse Auction at Anvil until such time as the Cinderpath Exchange is completed.
Outcome: Upheld (436 - 14). Raziel of the Shattered Tower provided 25 doses of liao to enact this mandate after the Winter Solstice 382YE.
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 33

Assembly: General
Raised By: Severin von Holberg
Judgement: The Way is an ever-evolving faith, whose truths must be Ambitiously pursued. While The Way of Sumaah fails to alter its Doctrines to address The Imperial Way's Doctrines of the Howling Abyss and the Ancestors, the Imperial Synod considers them nonconformist to the Imperial Way, but not enemies. We claim no temporal authority over those who look to Timoj, and we will continue to spiritually aid all those who cleave to the true Virtues. We fully reject any notion that the Sumaah Houses of Virtue have any authority over those who look to Bastion. Where souls can be saved by Sumaah, we will aid them, if they hinder us in the salvation of others, we will resist them. We send Severin von Holberg with 200 doses of liao to bring this message to all nations of the world, excepting Sumaah.
Outcome: Withdrawn at request of raising priest; when withdrawn there were 655 votes in favour and 321 against
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 34

Assembly: General
Raised By: Skywise Tulva
Judgement: Skarsind offers a welcome home for the slaves liberated from the Broken Shore. Just as we once fought for our freedom, so you will have a chance to fight against those who once enslaved you. Those who do not fight, will still have a place, working to support our legions. We send Skywise Tulva with 50 liao to encourage the slaves to settle in Skarsind and let them know that those who choose to adopt our ways will be able to become Imperial Orcs in time.
Outcome: Upheld and passed (1203 - 54). This judgement competes with Judgement 47 but achieved a margin of 1149. As such this mandate is considered to have been upheld. Skywise Tulva provided 50 doses of liao to enact this mandate after the Winter Solstice 382YE.
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 47

Assembly: General
Raised By: Arno von Leche
Judgement: Ambition is the lifeblood of the League. Near everyone who dreams of making something of their life, eventually finds their ways to one of the great cities of the Empire. We send Arno von Leche with 50 liao to encourage the slaves to settle in {named League city} and let them know of the many opportunities that await them there.
Outcome: Upheld but not passed (443 - 248). This mandate competes with Judgement 34. It received a margin of 195, and was defeated by the other mandate. It cannot be enacted.
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 55

Assembly: Brass Coast National
Raised By: Tiana i Zaydan i Riqueza
Judgement: Rescuing slaves is an act of great Virtue. Crushing a slave rebellion is an act that debases the Empire. We are born free, and it falls to us to uphold the right to a free life following the Way for all people. We send Tiana i Zaydan i Riqueza with 75 doses of liao to urge the people of the three tribes to take up arms and free not only the slaves of the Grendel, but those who had fought free who we condemned to return to their chains.
Outcome: The Empress used her Custodian of Virtue power to require that this mandate reach a greater majority to pass. The judgement was upheld (86 - 16) but failed to achieve the required greater majority.
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 66

Assembly: Varushka National
Raised By: Dovbravka Nadjaovna Vanek
Judgement: Vasili Zoryakovich Zverokaz reminds us that slavery is unacceptable; Eska Crowspeaker urges us to open out homes to those who have found freedom. Yet in Varushka we cannot simply accept a stranger at face-value, and must be certain of the nature of those we invite into our homes. We send Belakov the Wolf of Karsk with 150 doses of liao to examine each of these strangers and determine whether each one is friend or foe.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (106 - 0). Belakov Zakharovich Prochnost provided 150 doses of liao to enact this mandate after the Winter Solstice 382YE.
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Judgement 72

Assembly: Highguard National
Raised By: Shadrach
Judgement: The purpose of our pilgrimage is to save souls, those who have fallen to the vallorn, but also those who are lost to malign forces and who bend the knee to eternals. We send Shadrach with 25 liao to urge the grey pilgrims to preach the rejection of False Virtues and idolatrous behaviour.
Outcome: Upheld (343 - 20). Shadrach of Felix's Watch provided 25 doses of liao to enact this mandate after the Winter Solstice 382YE.
Notes: This opportunity is detailed here.

Evaluation

The Synod made the following judgements of excommunication, inquisition, revocation, and sanction.

Judgement 17

Assembly: Wisdom virtue
Raised By: Galene Netherwatch
Judgement: Vindication. Vindication of Aethelric Earldnedason, he preaches no heresy and is virtuous.
Outcome: Upheld (76 - 0)

Judgement 23

Assembly: Pride
Raised By: Genovera Barossa
Judgement: Inquisition. Alderai the Rapacious is called to Inquisition at 3:30pm at the hub to answer for their actions at the Meeting Place with the Jotun.
Outcome: Upheld (172 - 0)

Judgement 28

Assembly: General
Raised By: Chainspeaker Snark
Judgement: Inquisition. I, Chaplain Consular, call Jarrigk Orzel to Inquisition in the Imperial Orc fighting pit, at 1:30pm in the Winter Solstice 382YE.
Outcome: Automatically Upheld

Judgement 30

Assembly: General
Raised By: Vindictus
Judgement: Inquisition. The virtue inquisitor of Vigilance wishes to inquisit the advisor for vallorn affairs (Sian of Navarr) for actions involving Imperial citizens receiving infections from Llofir and walking the trods. 3pm - Eternal family.
Outcome: Upheld (487 - 0)

Judgement 36

Assembly: Wisdom
Raised By: Father Drakov
Judgement: Inquisition. I call to inquisition the following: Garston Wintersgrasp and Grenwatch of Wyvern's Watch of Wintermark. Inquisition to take place at 4pm on Saturday of Spring Summit 383YE at the Varushkan national hearth. They left a Varushkan to die, stepping over him as he bled out stating "Leave him he is not one of ours." They claim this was virtuous and wise.
Outcome: Upheld (150 - 0)

Judgement 37

Assembly: General
Raised By: Yarona of the Chantry
Judgement: Escalation:Vindication. Following thorough inquisition, I find Tarquinius Ankarien to be virtuous. I recommend the immediate reversal of his excommunication. His actions when dealing with slavers could be considered, in isolation, to be unvirtuous. However, to condemn him for this shows an incomplete understanding of the Prosperity inherent to his overall work towards ending slavery completely. This complicated matter perfectly illustrates the necessity of inquisition, prior to judgement.
Outcome: Upheld (819 - 48)

Judgement 38

Assembly: Loyalty
Raised By: Pan Edgestalker
Judgement: Inquisition. I call Emilia Ankarien to inquisition at 6pm Saturday at the hub to explain her actions during her tenure as Archmage of Winter, in regards to the ongoing tensions in the Conclave..
Outcome: Upheld (176 - 9)

Judgement 40

Assembly: General
Raised By: Maarit Suvidottir
Judgement: Inquisition. I call Medea Ruth to inquisition regarding her actions in Morrow. Occuring 6:10pm at the hub Saturday (or as soon as judgements read).
Outcome: Upheld (794 - 0)

Judgement 42

Assembly: Ambition
Raised By: Ranae de Rondell
Judgement: Inquisition. Last season the architect Frederick di Sarvos offered an opportunity to the Cardinal of Ambition, Viviane de Coeurdefer of Dawn. He offered to design something impressive under the guidance of the Cardinal. The request was duly made by the Cardinal, with the full support of the Ambition assembly. His designs have now been presented an the Ambition assembly call Frederick di Sarvos to Inquisition to answer questions on these designs and his reasoning. Furthermore we ask virtue can be seen or not seen in his actions. We call him to inquisition in the Glory square in Dawn at 4pm on the second day of the summit.
Outcome: Upheld (104 - 0); Frederick di Sarvos has confirmed his attendance but until the Inqusition is completely resolved the projects he has proposed may not go forward.

Judgement 52

Assembly: General
Raised By: Sister Meredith
Judgement: Inquisition. The Marcher Assembly calls Magistrate Ulrik to inquisition regarding the trial and subsequent execution of Froki, orc of the Mourn. The Inquisition will be held on Sunday, 13:30 at the Mandowla's Arms, the Marches.
Outcome: Upheld (588 - 12)

Judgement 54

Assembly: Marcher
Raised By: Brother Hugh of Bregasland
Judgement: Inquisition. General Will Talbot of the Drakes to attend inquisition at 10pm on Saturday at the hub to give his account of the attack of Alderley.
Outcome: Upheld (70 - 0); upheld with a Greater Majority.

Judgement 56

Assembly: General.
Raised By: Raelyn Holdfast
Judgement: Inquisition. I call Livia Cascade, seer of the Gateway, the Inquisition at 1:30pm on the Sunday of Winter Solstice.
Outcome: Upheld (488 - 0)

Judgement 58

Assembly: Pride
Raised By: Genovara Barossa
Judgement: Sanction:Penance (Escalation). Following his inquisition, it has been found that Alderei the Rapacious, intentionally destroyed the meeting place of the Jotun and the Winterfolk. As such, his penance shall be to have Winter magicians from Wintermark cast Freezing Brand of Irremais upon himself. The brand should state that "I deliberately destroyed an artefact of Winterfolk pride."
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (247 - 20).

Judgement 60

Assembly: General
Raised By: Rane Sherarding
Judgement: Escalation:Vindication. Escalation of Jugement 55, Autumn 382YE. Yarrick did everything in his power to prevent disruption of the inquisition of Skywise Gralka, Winter 381YE, and to protect her during. Offers were made to relocate or rearrange the procedure. He discharged his duties as inquisitor professionally.
Outcome: Upheld (721 - 10)

Judgement 61

Assembly: Pride
Raised By: Rane Sherarding
Judgement: Inquisition. I call Franco i Erigo to inquisition for his failure to provide the liao to fund a mandate he passed in Autumn 382YE. Hub. Noon. Sunday.
Outcome: Upheld (142 - 0)

Judgement 64

Assembly: the Way
Raised By: Bethany
Judgement: Castigation. Ulrick apologises for his lack of vigilance regarding his words in the trial of Gaston Coerdefeur, where he gave the wrong impression that a) he had "accepted" a clemency plea that he didn't think sufficient, and b) he was still considering the clemency plea when asking about other mitigating circumstances. Discussions have been had, and the magistrates encourage those who have given failed clemency pleas to speak to them about what went wrong so that misunderstandings do not persist on either side.
Outcome: Upheld (69 - 0)

Judgement 74

Assembly: General
Raised By: Vindictus
Judgement: Escalation: Vindication. After inquisition Sian the advisor for Vallorn affairs was found to have acted with due vigilance and wisdom dealing with Llofir.
Outcome: Upheld (681 - 10)

Judgement 76

Assembly: Highguard
Raised By: Yarona of the Chantry
Judgement: Inquisition. I call Ptolemy of Highguard to inquisition regarding his deal with the Whisper Gallery and subsequent actions. 9pm Friday next summit, Chantry tent, Highguard.
Outcome: Upheld (246 - 56)

Judgement 83

Assembly: Prosperity
Raised By: Giovanni di Tassato
Judgement: Inquisition. The assembly of Prosperity of the Imperial Synod call Bartimeus of Highguard, Overseer of the Vigilant Swan, to inquisition to account for the propriety of his conduct in office. Bartimeus is requested to provide relevant financial accounts at his inquisition to be overseen by Giovanni di Tassato of the assembly of Prosperity. Inquisition is to be held in the Civil Service hub at 18:30 at the Spring Summit of Anvil, Friday, 383YE
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (140 - 0)

Judgement 84

Assembly: Prosperity
Raised By: Cesare Enzo di Trivento
Judgement: Inquisition. We, the assembly of Prosperity of the Imperial Synod Esteban i Delrio Balnko i Guerra, the Imperial Fleet Master to inquisition to account for the conduct in office with regard to the spoils of the Dubhtraig raid. Inquisition to be held in the civil service hub, 2pm, Sunday Winter Summit 382YE.
Outcome: Upheld with a Greater Majority (146 - 0)

Judgement 85

Assembly: Courage
Raised By: Rafe
Judgement: Inquisition. I call Zofia Justywva Garnovska to inquisition at Spring 383 on Friday at 19:00 at the hub regarding events where she and her fellow magistrates came under threat of violence. Winter 382YE.
Outcome: Upheld (108 - 0)

Recognition

The following judgements of recognition were presented during the Winter Solstice.

Judgement 6

Assembly: General
Raised By: Brodi Brackensong
Judgement: Gerallt Brackensong, founder of Songs and Stories, should be recognised as an exemplar of Pride, as has already been agreed by the Pride Assmbly. Details on the board.
Outcome: Upheld (713 - 130).

Appointment

At the Summit, the following appointments were proposed by the Assemblies of the Synod. You can find the names of citizens who currently hold Imperial titles in the Synod here.

Judgement 1

Assembly: Prosperity
Raised by: Tribune
Judgement: Appointment of the Cardinal.
Outcome: Onan of the Chantry of the Silver Skull was appointed with 134 votes. Cesare Enzo di Trivento received 66 votes.

Judgement 2

Assembly: Way
Raised by: Tribune
Judgement: Appointment of the Cardinal.
Outcome: Hywel Summercrow was appointed with 117 votes. Atla of the Imperial Orcs received 54 votes.

Judgement 12

Assembly: Navarr
Raised by: Tribune
Judgement: Appointment of the Voice of Barbs.
Outcome: Meredith Nighthaven was appointed with 72 votes. Brat Umbral Path received 10 votes.

Judgement 15

Assembly: Courage
Raised by: Tribune
Judgement: Appointment of the Virtue inquisitor.
Outcome: Rafe of Fjellraven Hall was appointed with 40 votes.

Judgement 19

Assembly: Nine
Raised by: Tribune
Judgement: Appointment of the High Exorcist.
Outcome: Solas of the Spire of the Waxing Sun was appointed with 4 votes. Ozren de Orzel received 1 vote.

Judgement 29

Assembly: Wisdom
Raised by: Tribune
Judgement: Appointment of the Virtue inquisitor.
Outcome: Galene Netherwatch was appointed with 118 votes. Cimies of Felix's Watch received 38 votes.

Judgement 32

Assembly: Brass Coast
Raised by: Tribune
Judgement: Appointment of the Liaison to the Temple in Nemoria.
Outcome: Franco i Erigo was appointed with 62 votes.

Judgement 93

Assembly: Marches
Raised by: Albert Fugglestone Copperhill
Judgement: We the Marcher assembly reinstate Albert Fugglestone Copperhill to the position of Friar of Honour's Rest.
Outcome: Albert Fugglestone Copperhill was appointed with 76 votes (primacy).

Rewarding

The following judgements of rewarding were proposed during the Winter Solstice.

Judgement 7

Assembly: General Assembly
Raised By: Chauntecleer Words
Judgement: Salvation is a sign of the Exemplar and Paragon, and so all virtue should strive to expand the reach of the Way not just by the sword but also by affirming the faith of believers and bringing new ones to the path. There are Suranni followers of the Way, but they face persecution for their belief. Without access to liao to bolster them we may soon see them expunged, and their candle in the dark snuffed out. We have an opportunity to construct brokerages within the Empire where they may legally acquire liao for a fair bargain, that there will continue to be a presence of the Way and perhaps the chance to offer Salvation to more souls.We estimate to construct such endeavours will be of the order of 60 Thrones for the required 8 white granite and 8 weirwood. Respecting the other demands on the virtue fund, we would ask our fellows to provide 30 Thrones this season, and a second motion will be proposed next season for the remainder. Any unused funds would be returned to the virtue fund, and we would hope that any eventual custodian of the brokerage also remember their provenance should they result in prosperity.
Outcome: Upheld (413 - 243); 30 Thrones provided by the Tribune

Judgement 48

Assembly: General Assembly
Raised By: Efenia i Maristella i Riqueza
Judgement: The Axou confederacy is on the brink of civil war between pro slavery and anti-slavery factions. The Synod awards 25 Thrones to the Ambassador of Axos to lend economic aid to the citadels who wish to end slavery.
Outcome: Upheld (550 - 71); 25 Thrones paid by the Tribune.

Judgement 57

Assembly: General Assembly
Raised By: Corwyn Leafstalker
Judgement: As Imperial Inquisitor I have had the idea that I would like a sum of 30 Thrones from the virtue fund to be able to offer a bounty for any information that leads to the positive identification of a heretic. Even if I caught no heretics through this, it will make things harder for cults operating in Anvil. Is this a good use of the virtue fund? I think so but fortunately I get to check by putting the question to you. Thanks for your time. Corwyn.
Outcome: Not Upheld (149 - 243)

Judgement 77

Assembly: General Assembly
Raised By: Solas
Judgement: As High Exorcist I withdraw 7 Thrones from the virtue fund, pursuant to my duties. This is on the understanding that this reverts to a Senate stipend as soon as economically feasible.
Outcome: Automatically Upheld; 7 Thrones paid by the Tribune.

Judgement 81

Assembly: General Assembly
Raised By: Skywise Fal
Judgement: Myself an the consulate would wish to celebrate the virtuous actions of all of the Ambassadors and participants in the Liberty Pact summit. We have made history this season and virtue must be rewarded. I wish to reward; Thanmir Hrafnar, Tarquinius Ankarien, Lucia Sanguineo di Tassato, Accalon of Felix's Watch, Eska Crowspeaker, Ianthe of the Sons of Couros, Atte Arrowtongue, Rodrigo Barossa, and John Cooper the sum of 5 Thrones each totaling 45 Thrones.
Outcome: Upheld (823 - 0); 45 Thrones paid by the Tribune

The Virtue Fund

The following represents the Virtue Fund of the Synod:

Starting Value	Nil
Income	110 Thrones	The price paid in the Bourse Auction for the dose of True Liao.
Income	10 Rings	Donation from an anonymous citizen.
Income	2 Thrones, 4 Crowns	Donation from an anonymous citizen.
Income	4 Thrones, 6 Crowns, 5 Rings	Donation from Brat Umbral Path.
Rewarding	30 Thrones	Rewarding to Chauntecleer Words following Judgement 7 being upheld.
Rewarding	25 Thrones	Rewarding to Efenia i Maristella i Riqueza following Judgement 48 being upheld.
Rewarding	7 Thrones	Rewarding to Solas following Judgement 77 being automatically upheld.
Rewarding	45 Thrones	Rewarding to Skywise Fal following Judgement 81 being automatically upheld.
Closing Value	10 Thrones, 2 Crowns, 15 Rings

Visionaries

The following individuals received visions of their past lives.

Atte Arrow-tongue
Ulric Y'basden.

Assembly Strength

At the start of the summit the voting total of the General Assembly was calculated to be 2598.

The final voting total of the General Assembly was calculated to be 2949.

The Civil Service reminds citizens that determining whether a Judgement has achieved a Greater Majority counts from the estimation of the relevant Assembly strength when scrutiny on the Judgement closes, not the final Assembly strength at the end of the summit.

At the end of the Winter Solstice 382YE Summit the voting strength of the Virtue and National Assemblies were estimated to be:

Virtue Assembly	Initial Voting Strength	Final Voting Strength	Final Greater Majority
Ambition	270	290	146
Courage	246	300	151
Loyalty	379	431	216
Pride	346	436	219
Prosperity	252	272	137
Vigilance	385	447	224
Wisdom	309	331	166
The Way	411	442	222
General	2598	2949	1480

National Assembly	Initial Voting Strength	Final Voting Strength	Final Greater Majority
Brass Coast	178	188	95
Dawn	182	256	129
Highguard	842	902	452
Imperial Orcs	123	134	68
The League	264	306	154
The Marches	82	142	72
Navarr	240	270	136
Urizen	105	127	64
Varushka	188	198	100
Wintermark	394	426	214
General	2598	2949	1484