Appraisal - Revision history

Rafferty: /* Previous Appraisals */

2026-03-23T14:06:22Z

Previous Appraisals

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:06, 23 March 2026
Line 67:		Line 67:
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Society_of_Inspiration\|Society of Inspiration]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Society_of_Inspiration\|Society of Inspiration]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Ministries\|Ministries]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Graciana i Lòpez i Guerra</td><td>[[The circle game]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Ministries\|Ministries]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Graciana i Lòpez i Guerra assigned</td><td>[[The circle game]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Port_in_Utterlund\|Port in Utterlund]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[Any port in a storm]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Port_in_Utterlund\|Port in Utterlund]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[Any port in a storm]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Food_and_Water_of_Holberg\|Supplies of Holberg]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>[[Threats that are to come]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Food_and_Water_of_Holberg\|Supplies of Holberg]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>[[Threats that are to come]]</td></tr>

Rafferty: /* Previous Appraisals */

2026-03-23T14:05:58Z

Previous Appraisals

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:05, 23 March 2026
Line 67:		Line 67:
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Society_of_Inspiration\|Society of Inspiration]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Society_of_Inspiration\|Society of Inspiration]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Ministries\|Ministries]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Graciana i Lòpez i Guerra</td><td>~~Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE~~</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Ministries\|Ministries]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Graciana i Lòpez i Guerra</td><td>[[The circle game]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Port_in_Utterlund\|Port in Utterlund]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[Any port in a storm]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Port_in_Utterlund\|Port in Utterlund]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[Any port in a storm]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Food_and_Water_of_Holberg\|Supplies of Holberg]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>[[Threats that are to come]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Food_and_Water_of_Holberg\|Supplies of Holberg]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>[[Threats that are to come]]</td></tr>

Thespaceinvader: /* Previous Appraisals */

2026-03-12T11:03:22Z

Previous Appraisals

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:03, 12 March 2026
Line 63:		Line 63:
	<tr><td>'''Appraisal'''</td><td>'''Date'''</td><td>'''Senate Decision'''</td><td>'''Civil Servant'''</td><td>'''Outcome'''</td></tr>		<tr><td>'''Appraisal'''</td><td>'''Date'''</td><td>'''Senate Decision'''</td><td>'''Civil Servant'''</td><td>'''Outcome'''</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[My friends are my estate]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[My friends are my estate]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>The truth but tell it slant]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>[[The truth but tell it slant]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>

Thespaceinvader: /* Previous Appraisals */

2026-03-12T11:03:13Z

Previous Appraisals

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:03, 12 March 2026
Line 63:		Line 63:
	<tr><td>'''Appraisal'''</td><td>'''Date'''</td><td>'''Senate Decision'''</td><td>'''Civil Servant'''</td><td>'''Outcome'''</td></tr>		<tr><td>'''Appraisal'''</td><td>'''Date'''</td><td>'''Senate Decision'''</td><td>'''Civil Servant'''</td><td>'''Outcome'''</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[My friends are my estate]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[My friends are my estate]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>The truth but tell it slant</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>The truth but tell it slant]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>

Thespaceinvader: /* Previous Appraisals */

2026-03-12T11:03:01Z

Previous Appraisals

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:03, 12 March 2026
Line 63:		Line 63:
	<tr><td>'''Appraisal'''</td><td>'''Date'''</td><td>'''Senate Decision'''</td><td>'''Civil Servant'''</td><td>'''Outcome'''</td></tr>		<tr><td>'''Appraisal'''</td><td>'''Date'''</td><td>'''Senate Decision'''</td><td>'''Civil Servant'''</td><td>'''Outcome'''</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[My friends are my estate]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[My friends are my estate]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>~~Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE~~</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>The truth but tell it slant</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>
Line 123:		Line 123:
	It is usually better to avoid outlining a method for the appraisal, as this can lead to disappointment if it isn't possible to solve the problem that way. However, it is also better to avoid defining the outcome you want - since that outcome may not be possible. A motion that clearly states what problem the Senate would like addressed is the best way to maximise your chances that the results achieve what the Empire wants.		It is usually better to avoid outlining a method for the appraisal, as this can lead to disappointment if it isn't possible to solve the problem that way. However, it is also better to avoid defining the outcome you want - since that outcome may not be possible. A motion that clearly states what problem the Senate would like addressed is the best way to maximise your chances that the results achieve what the Empire wants.
	</box></div>		</box></div>

	==OOC Design==		==OOC Design==
	An appraisal is designed to allow the Imperial Senate to direct the civil service to look for a new solution to an existing problem facing it. Inline with the broad remit of the Senate, this could be economic, magical, military or religious in nature. The normal powers of the Senate allow the institute to address a wide range of problems using well-known and clearly defined powers. For instance, fortifications can be built, armies raised, navies constructed. They can disburse the contents of the Imperial treasury, make declarations of war or peace and so on.		An appraisal is designed to allow the Imperial Senate to direct the civil service to look for a new solution to an existing problem facing it. Inline with the broad remit of the Senate, this could be economic, magical, military or religious in nature. The normal powers of the Senate allow the institute to address a wide range of problems using well-known and clearly defined powers. For instance, fortifications can be built, armies raised, navies constructed. They can disburse the contents of the Imperial treasury, make declarations of war or peace and so on.

Matt at 10:54, 12 March 2026

2026-03-12T10:54:46Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:54, 12 March 2026
Line 48:		Line 48:
	===Lutomysla Niegoslava===		===Lutomysla Niegoslava===
	Lutomysla is an experienced [[cabalists\|cabalist]] from [[Karov]] who sees magic as the most effective tool to address complex situations. They served for a time as [[Archmage of Night]] during the reign of [[Emperor Hugh]], and after stepping down from the title joined the Civil Service as an aide to the [[Conclave]]. Unlike their predecessor Mladen Excovitch, Lutomysla is unlikely to be concerned about efficiency or parsimony. Rather, they are interested in identifying practical magical solutions to problems.		Lutomysla is an experienced [[cabalists\|cabalist]] from [[Karov]] who sees magic as the most effective tool to address complex situations. They served for a time as [[Archmage of Night]] during the reign of [[Emperor Hugh]], and after stepping down from the title joined the Civil Service as an aide to the [[Conclave]]. Unlike their predecessor Mladen Excovitch, Lutomysla is unlikely to be concerned about efficiency or parsimony. Rather, they are interested in identifying practical magical solutions to problems.
			{{CaptionedImage\|file=Draughir.jpg\|align=right\|width=400}}
	If the Senate instructs Lutomysla to carry out an appraisal then the work will focus on magical solutions. They are not interested solely with ritual magic; as a cabalist they are practiced at dealing with powers such as eternals or even sovereigns and have made an extensive study of esoteric magics such as [[hearth magic]], peculiar [[regio]], [[astronomancy\|astronomantic]] [[Astronomancy#Tulpas\|tulpas]] and even more obscure occult topics.		If the Senate instructs Lutomysla to carry out an appraisal then the work will focus on magical solutions. They are not interested solely with ritual magic; as a cabalist they are practiced at dealing with powers such as eternals or even sovereigns and have made an extensive study of esoteric magics such as [[hearth magic]], peculiar [[regio]], [[astronomancy\|astronomantic]] [[Astronomancy#Tulpas\|tulpas]] and even more obscure occult topics.
	===Eilian Sweetwater===		===Eilian Sweetwater===
Line 54:		Line 54:

	If the Senate instructs Eilian to carry out an appraisal then the work will be firmly grounded in the Empire's history. This might mean revisiting and reassessing historical proposals, building on past discoveries and theories, or finding inspiration in the stories and traditions of the ten nations. He's also a Navarr, and where history provides no guidance he will fall back on the most practical solution - although just like his colleague Graciana he recognises that "practical" sometimes means ''expensive''.		If the Senate instructs Eilian to carry out an appraisal then the work will be firmly grounded in the Empire's history. This might mean revisiting and reassessing historical proposals, building on past discoveries and theories, or finding inspiration in the stories and traditions of the ten nations. He's also a Navarr, and where history provides no guidance he will fall back on the most practical solution - although just like his colleague Graciana he recognises that "practical" sometimes means ''expensive''.
	~~{{CaptionedImage\|file=Draughir.jpg\|align=right\|width=400}}~~
	===Retired Prognosticators===		===Retired Prognosticators===
	====Mladen Escovitch====		====Mladen Escovitch====

Matt at 10:54, 12 March 2026

2026-03-12T10:54:31Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:54, 12 March 2026
Line 54:		Line 54:

	If the Senate instructs Eilian to carry out an appraisal then the work will be firmly grounded in the Empire's history. This might mean revisiting and reassessing historical proposals, building on past discoveries and theories, or finding inspiration in the stories and traditions of the ten nations. He's also a Navarr, and where history provides no guidance he will fall back on the most practical solution - although just like his colleague Graciana he recognises that "practical" sometimes means ''expensive''.		If the Senate instructs Eilian to carry out an appraisal then the work will be firmly grounded in the Empire's history. This might mean revisiting and reassessing historical proposals, building on past discoveries and theories, or finding inspiration in the stories and traditions of the ten nations. He's also a Navarr, and where history provides no guidance he will fall back on the most practical solution - although just like his colleague Graciana he recognises that "practical" sometimes means ''expensive''.
			{{CaptionedImage\|file=Draughir.jpg\|align=right\|width=400}}
	===Retired Prognosticators===		===Retired Prognosticators===
	====Mladen Escovitch====		====Mladen Escovitch====
Line 113:		Line 113:
	</table>		</table>
	</onlyinclude>		</onlyinclude>
	~~{{CaptionedImage\|file=Draughir.jpg\|align=right\|width=400}}~~


			<div style="max-width: 500px; width: 50%; float: right;"><box>
			====Appraisal Structure====
			<p>Any appraisal involves three elements - the first is the fundamental problem that the players wish to overcome or address. The second element, is the method - the way that the problem will be addressed. The final part is the outcome - the result that will occur if the methods outlined are enacted by the Empire.</p>

			The crucial information needed by the plot team to write a useful appraisal response is a clear outline of the problem that the Empire wants addressed. Only if we are certain what problem the players want to deal with can we be confident that the solutions we present will address those issues. We don't want to give players possible solutions to different problems.

			It is usually better to avoid outlining a method for the appraisal, as this can lead to disappointment if it isn't possible to solve the problem that way. However, it is also better to avoid defining the outcome you want - since that outcome may not be possible. A motion that clearly states what problem the Senate would like addressed is the best way to maximise your chances that the results achieve what the Empire wants.
			</box></div>
	==OOC Design==		==OOC Design==
	An appraisal is designed to allow the Imperial Senate to direct the civil service to look for a new solution to an existing problem facing it. Inline with the broad remit of the Senate, this could be economic, magical, military or religious in nature. The normal powers of the Senate allow the institute to address a wide range of problems using well-known and clearly defined powers. For instance, fortifications can be built, armies raised, navies constructed. They can disburse the contents of the Imperial treasury, make declarations of war or peace and so on.		An appraisal is designed to allow the Imperial Senate to direct the civil service to look for a new solution to an existing problem facing it. Inline with the broad remit of the Senate, this could be economic, magical, military or religious in nature. The normal powers of the Senate allow the institute to address a wide range of problems using well-known and clearly defined powers. For instance, fortifications can be built, armies raised, navies constructed. They can disburse the contents of the Imperial treasury, make declarations of war or peace and so on.

Rafferty: /* Previous Appraisals */

2026-02-27T18:12:42Z

Previous Appraisals

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:12, 27 February 2026
Line 62:		Line 62:
	<table class="wikitable">		<table class="wikitable">
	<tr><td>'''Appraisal'''</td><td>'''Date'''</td><td>'''Senate Decision'''</td><td>'''Civil Servant'''</td><td>'''Outcome'''</td></tr>		<tr><td>'''Appraisal'''</td><td>'''Date'''</td><td>'''Senate Decision'''</td><td>'''Civil Servant'''</td><td>'''Outcome'''</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>~~Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE~~</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[My friends are my estate]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>

Rafferty: /* Previous Appraisals */

2026-02-24T12:38:27Z

Previous Appraisals

← Older revision		Revision as of 12:38, 24 February 2026
Line 64:		Line 64:
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>~~Presented before~~ the ~~Winter Solstice 387YE~~</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Society_of_Inspiration\|Society of Inspiration]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Society_of_Inspiration\|Society of Inspiration]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>

Matt: /* The Results of the Appraisal */

2026-02-11T10:41:53Z

The Results of the Appraisal

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:41, 11 February 2026
Line 27:		Line 27:
	The civil service will produce a detailed report outlining every opportunity that has been identified during the course of the appraisal. This will be widely published alongside the normal reports in the weeks immediately preceding the summit to allow those planning to attend the summit to consider the matter carefully. The report will be complete, which is to say that it will identify all options that exist currently; unless the report explicitly indicates otherwise it should be understood to cover every option available. There is no benefit in instructing the civil service to carry out the same appraisal unless the extenuating circumstances have substantially altered in the meantime.		The civil service will produce a detailed report outlining every opportunity that has been identified during the course of the appraisal. This will be widely published alongside the normal reports in the weeks immediately preceding the summit to allow those planning to attend the summit to consider the matter carefully. The report will be complete, which is to say that it will identify all options that exist currently; unless the report explicitly indicates otherwise it should be understood to cover every option available. There is no benefit in instructing the civil service to carry out the same appraisal unless the extenuating circumstances have substantially altered in the meantime.

	~~The report will aim to be concise, so it may leave out explicit references to elements of the situation examined that make it unique.~~ The appraisal should be understood to apply ''only'' to the location and scenario laid out in the report. Unless otherwise noted, options that may exist to address the problem are not applicable elsewhere. An appraisal which identifies an opportunity to build a navy in Meade, is specific to a navy in Meade - it does not apply to Sarvos or any other location. Nor does it apply to an army or a fortification. Any options that exist to vary what can be achieved will be explicitly laid out in the report.		The appraisal should be understood to apply ''only'' to the location and scenario laid out in the report. Unless otherwise noted, options that may exist to address the problem are not applicable elsewhere. An appraisal which identifies an opportunity to build a navy in Meade, is specific to a navy in Meade - it does not apply to Sarvos or any other location. Nor does it apply to an army or a fortification. Any options that exist to vary what can be achieved will be explicitly laid out in the report.

	If the appraisal identifies any opportunities which are time-limited, that is they are only valid if carried out within a limited time-frame, then this will be made clear in the report.		If the appraisal identifies any opportunities which are time-limited, that is they are only valid if carried out within a limited time-frame, then this will be made clear in the report.

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:06, 23 March 2026
Line 67:		Line 67:
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Society_of_Inspiration\|Society of Inspiration]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Society_of_Inspiration\|Society of Inspiration]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Ministries\|Ministries]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Graciana i Lòpez i Guerra</td><td>[[The circle game]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Ministries\|Ministries]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Graciana i Lòpez i Guerra assigned</td><td>[[The circle game]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Port_in_Utterlund\|Port in Utterlund]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[Any port in a storm]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Port_in_Utterlund\|Port in Utterlund]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[Any port in a storm]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Food_and_Water_of_Holberg\|Supplies of Holberg]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>[[Threats that are to come]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Food_and_Water_of_Holberg\|Supplies of Holberg]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>[[Threats that are to come]]</td></tr>

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:05, 23 March 2026
Line 67:		Line 67:
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Society_of_Inspiration\|Society of Inspiration]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Society_of_Inspiration\|Society of Inspiration]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Ministries\|Ministries]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Graciana i Lòpez i Guerra</td><td>~~Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE~~</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Ministries\|Ministries]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Graciana i Lòpez i Guerra</td><td>[[The circle game]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Port_in_Utterlund\|Port in Utterlund]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[Any port in a storm]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Port_in_Utterlund\|Port in Utterlund]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[Any port in a storm]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Food_and_Water_of_Holberg\|Supplies of Holberg]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>[[Threats that are to come]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Summer_Solstice_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Food_and_Water_of_Holberg\|Supplies of Holberg]]</td><td>Summer 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>[[Threats that are to come]]</td></tr>

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:03, 12 March 2026
Line 63:		Line 63:
	<tr><td>'''Appraisal'''</td><td>'''Date'''</td><td>'''Senate Decision'''</td><td>'''Civil Servant'''</td><td>'''Outcome'''</td></tr>		<tr><td>'''Appraisal'''</td><td>'''Date'''</td><td>'''Senate Decision'''</td><td>'''Civil Servant'''</td><td>'''Outcome'''</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[My friends are my estate]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[My friends are my estate]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>The truth but tell it slant]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>[[The truth but tell it slant]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:03, 12 March 2026
Line 63:		Line 63:
	<tr><td>'''Appraisal'''</td><td>'''Date'''</td><td>'''Senate Decision'''</td><td>'''Civil Servant'''</td><td>'''Outcome'''</td></tr>		<tr><td>'''Appraisal'''</td><td>'''Date'''</td><td>'''Senate Decision'''</td><td>'''Civil Servant'''</td><td>'''Outcome'''</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[My friends are my estate]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>[[My friends are my estate]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>The truth but tell it slant</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>The truth but tell it slant]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>

← Older revision		Revision as of 12:38, 24 February 2026
Line 64:		Line 64:
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Prosperity_of_Spiral\|Prosperity of Spiral]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Naomi of Virtue's Rest</td><td>Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Expansion_of_Printer's_Guild\|Expansion of Printer's Guild]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Professor Immanuel Gelberg</td><td>Presented before the Winter Solstice 387YE</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>~~Presented before~~ the ~~Winter Solstice 387YE~~</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Bridges_in_Brass_Coast\|Bridges in the Brass Coast]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Passed</td><td>Lutomysla Niegoslava</td><td>[[Mermaids in the basement]]</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Exploration_of_Tsirku\|Exploration of Tsirku]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>
	<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Society_of_Inspiration\|Society of Inspiration]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>		<tr><td>[[387YE_Autumn_Equinox_Senate_sessions#Appraise_Society_of_Inspiration\|Society of Inspiration]]</td><td>Autumn 387YE</td><td>Withdrawn</td><td>Nobody requested</td><td>No appraisal</td></tr>